|
**** PLEASE NOTE ****
Some sessions
Wednesday afternoon will be held on the campus of the University of
Arkansas-Little Rock. Several of these are designed to take advantage
of advanced learning technologies available on campus, and include training
and demonstration sessions. Additionally, the keynote address and Joint
Universities Reception will be hosted by UALR.
Busses
will begin running between the Doubletree and UALR well in advance of
the sessions. The scheduled departures are as follows:
Doubletree
to UALR: 1:45 p.m., 2:45 p.m., 4:00 pm, and 4:30 p.m.
UALR to
Doubletree: 7:30 p.m. and 8:30 p.m.
The trip
takes approximately 30 minutes please plan your schedule accordingly.
9:30 A.M. - 10:20 A.M.
Session 1.1 TEACHER EDUCATION / CERTIFICATION Salon
A
Chair: Linda F. Cornelious, Mississippi State University
Alternative Certification Program: A Collaborative
Effort Between Hamilton County Department of Education and The University
of Tennessee at Chattanooga Evaluation
Cynthia M. Gettys and Jane T. Brower,
The University of Tennessee at Chattanooga
Early in the 1980s,
the National Center for Education Statistics (NCEI) erroneously predicted
a dramatic shortage of teachers by 1992. States began to look for ways
to certify more teachers more quickly than the typical four-year undergraduate
teacher education program. By 2000, 47 states, plus the District of
Columbia, reported having some type of alternative teacher certification
program to the NCEI, that has been polling the state departments of
education annually since 1983 regarding teacher education and certification.
By 2000, a shortage
of teachers had emerged. This research paper summarized and evaluated
the Alternative Certification Program jointly developed by the Hamilton
County Department of Education (HCDE) and The University of Tennessee
at Chattanooga (UTC), and shared data evaluating the program by all
participants enrolled in Cohorts I and II. While telling an ethnographic
story, this paper included statistical comparisons between and among
cohort groups. All recorded voices were active participants from the
university, the local education agency, or both cohort groups that have
become the first alternatively certified teachers in Hamilton County,
Tennessee. The data were compiled through the administration of an open-ended
survey.
Cohort I was formed
with the selection of 12 individuals in May 1999. Seventy-five percent
of the first cohort group completed its first year of teaching on June
1, 2000 and signed contracts committing to return to their classrooms
for a second and now a third year. Ninety-five percent of the second
cohort group completed its first year of teaching on June 1, 2001 and
signed contracts committing to return to their classrooms for a second
year. One hundred percent of both cohorts returned completed surveys.
Building a Model to Predict Which Students Will Pass the Praxis I Exams
for Arkansas
Linda H. Thornton, Harding University
Complex policy
issues surround the stringency of teacher licensure exams. Many states,
including Arkansas, have recently raised minimum passing scores on the
Praxis I exam. Gitomer, Latham, and Ziomek (1997) found that those
who passed the Praxis I exams had higher SAT/ACT scores and grade point
averages than those who failed. In the interest of maintaining a diverse
pool of prospective teachers, it is important that teacher preparation
institutions assist promising teacher candidates in meeting licensure
requirements. Institutions should have a model using admission test
scores and class grades to predict which students might require extensive
help in meeting licensure requirements.
All possible models
comprised of different subsets of predictor variables were analyzed
using discriminant analysis cross-validated with leave-one-out classification
estimates. The degree to which each model performed better than proportional
chance was tested with Huberty's (1994) z statistic.
Legal Issues To Be Considered When Testing Teachers for Initial Licensing
Donna Pascoe and Glennelle Halpin, Auburn
University
Do teachers have
the basic minimum competencies to be effective educators? To answer
this question, the school reform movement experiencing rapid public
acceptance is teacher testing. Standardized criterion-referenced tests
provide a quick, easy, and observable measure of whether or not a teacher
candidate possesses the basic minimum competencies required to receive
initial teacher licensure.
Implementing a testing
program is not as simple as one might think. As with all tests, teacher-licensing
exams must be valid, reliable, fair, and legally defensible. Court decisions
have impacted teacher testing by attempting to resolve both technical
and social problems associated with testing. Legal actions related to
testing have helped to define the direction of the competency-based
testing movement. Individuals responsible for teacher testing programs
must have a working understanding of what makes a test valid, reliable,
and unbiased as well as an understanding of how and when testing may
be used.
This review covered
the test components of validity, reliability, job-relatedness, and test
bias as determined by impact for teacher licensing exams. The literature
provided a history of court decisions and legal rulings that have shaped
policy, test design, and use. The two most influential resources and
those that provide operational direction for test construction, use,
and evaluation of test results have been the 1978 revised edition of
the Uniform Guidelines on Employee Selection Procedures (1978/2000)
and the revised edition of the Standards for Educational and Psychological
Testing (AERA et al., 1999). A review of the important criteria for
implementing a fair and legal testing program was discussed, along with
guidelines that provided a framework for determining the proper use
of tests and other selection procedures. Licensing and certification
boards from State Departments of Education would benefit from this review
of literature as it pertains to testing requirements determined by federal
law and psychometric practices.
Session 1.2 SCHOOL IMPROVEMENT / PLANNING Salon B
Chair:
Jack Klotz, The University of Southern Mississippi
Ensuring the Viability of Curriculum
Mapping in a School Improvement Plan
Michael S. Mills, University of Arkansas
at Little Rock
This paper focused
on the initial phase of a curriculum-mapping program as part of the
development of a state-mandated school improvement plan. Mapping, a
system of curriculum analysis and subsequent alignment, has been cited
as a valuable component of curriculum renewal and staff development
(English, 1984; Jacobs, 1997). Further research has described the efficacy
and positive impact that curriculum mapping has on student achievement
and teacher job satisfaction. Particularly valuable has been the much-needed
flexibility to address the changing curricular needs of each school
district, as well as the anticipated level of teacher participation
respective to curriculum restructuring.
The state of Arkansas
has mandated that curriculum mapping be an integral component of the
ACSIP (Arkansas Consolidated School Improvement Plan) process but has
left school districts with no formal or structured guidance for this
aspect of school improvement planning. However, school districts in
Arkansas have banded together in electronic message boards and professional
workshops to get a sense of how to make this innovative program of curriculum
mapping work. Yet, there has been little evidence that a wholehearted
commitment to mapping has been made statewide. Given this perspective,
this paper attempted to address concerns of administrators and teachers
mired in this stage of the school improvement process.
This paper shared
various observations and guidelines respective to the strategic implementation
of a curriculum-mapping plan within the framework of the school improvement
process. Particular areas of concern included the following: (1) districtwide
efforts to account for site-based flexibility, (2) development of a
unified computer curriculum-mapping database, (3) guidelines for securing
genuine staff adoption of a curriculum-mapping proposal, and (4) long-term
planning aimed at sustaining staff interest and commitment.
Team Teaching
in the Elementary School: A Long‑Term Qualitative Study of Teacher
Planning and Decision‑Making
John F. Riley, The University of Montevallo
This study synthesized
three phases of a longitudinal case study of collaborative planning
and decision making in a grade-level team of elementary teachers. The
purpose of this study was to examine planning and decision making of
an elementary grade-level team during grade-level team meetings.
Twelve elementary
teachers in a suburban school district in the Mid-South participated
in this study over a three-year period. They ranged from beginning
teachers to those with more than ten years' teaching experience. One
teacher was African American; the others were white, non-Hispanic.
All teachers were members of a grade-level team that met together to
plan and carry out administrative functions.
Teachers were observed
during regular weekly team planning meetings, some for curriculum planning,
and some for team business. Team captains conducted all of these meetings.
During these meetings, levels of participation of team members were
initially recorded, and the types of interactions were categorized.
In the second phase, field notes on discussion topics and actions toward
consensus and decision making were compiled. In the third phase, team
members were interviewed with regard to their perceptions of team teaching
in general, the functioning of this team in particular, their role in
shared decision making, and their perceptions of the evolving roles
of team members because of changes in personnel. Teachers on this
team participated in interviews of prospective teachers for the team,
and they also responded to questions regarding their participation in
this process.
These data provided
a rich source for analysis. Critical issues addressed in this paper
included the role of the team captain, the effect of variations in experience
and philosophical stance among team members on team functioning, the
role of continuity (and the lack of it) in teambuilding, and the value
of team planning in the induction of beginning teachers.
Assessing the Core Beliefs of School Staff:
A Local School District's Experience in Operationalizing a Strategic
Plan
James R. Hutto, Petal (Mississippi)
School District, and Robin K. Henson, University of North Texas
Strategic plans
are useful in guiding decision making and action in school districts.
However, the beliefs of persons in a school district must be the foundation
of the strategic plan and must represent a set of commonly held beliefs
by the various groups that make up the community. To optimize effectiveness,
school districts must take into account the personal beliefs of school
employees as they relate to the strategic plan and develop means to
assess these beliefs in prospective employees.
This paper described
one school district's experience in developing an instrument to be used
in assessing the core beliefs of a recently developed strategic plan.
The discussion (1) documents the activities of the school district and
(2) serves as a possible model for other school districts seeking to
develop similar instruments to assess the beliefs of their school personnel
as related to the school's vision or strategic plan.
The local district
identified seven core beliefs that have been proposed as central to
the strategic plan and effective education. These seven beliefs were
operationalized in an instrument for use in assessing the degree the
beliefs are held in current and future employees. Two studies were
conducted. The first study involved initial item development and content
validation procedures using administrator perspectives on the core beliefs.
The second study involved administering the survey to all school employees
and examining the factorial structure of the items. Exploratory factor
analysis resulted in a parsimonious one-factor solution globally capturing
all seven core belief areas with the factor explaining 42.5% of correlation
matrix (15 items).
Implications for
use of the instrument in the current district were discussed, as well
as possibilities for the current process to be used as a model for other
districts attempting to quantitatively operationalize the key beliefs
in their strategic plans.
Session 1.3 COLLEGE STUDENTS Salon C
Chair:
Thelma J. Roberson, The University of Southern Mississippi
Do Self-Efficacy, Self-Regulation,
and Good Study Skills Equal Academic Success?
Geraldine Smith‑Mallette, Linda
W. Morse, Christy Derby, Jimmy Henderson, Jeanette Roberts, and Ronica
Arnold, Mississippi State University
Though literature
has supported the idea that self-efficacy, self-regulation, and good
study habits enhance one's chances of academic success, little research
exists that has looked at these three aspects collectively. This study
investigated how college undergraduate students perceived their own
sense of self-efficacy, self-regulation, and study skills as they related
to their academic success as a whole.
Participants included
110 undergraduates from a variety of majors who completed a 40-item
questionnaire consisting of measures assessing their self-efficacy,
self-regulation skills, and study skills. The 40-item questionnaire
was answered on a five-point Likert scale ranging from 1 - definitely
disagree to 5 - definitely agree, with 3 being neutral. The questionnaire
was composed of questions about study skills, self-efficacy, and self-regulation
skills.
Academic success
was defined by the student's grade point average (GPA). At the .01 alpha
level, using the Pearson correlation, the correlation between GPA and
self-regulation skills was statistically significant. The correlation
between GPA and self -efficacy was also statistically significant. However,
the correlation between GPA and study skills was not statistically significant
at the .01 alpha level.
This study offered
further evidence that self-regulation and self-efficacy are positively
associated with academic success. Although good study skills are usually
associated with academic success, no evidence existed to support an
association between study skills and academic success for this particular
group of undergraduate students.
Practical Prediction
of Student Engagement in a College Self-Paced Introductory Psychology
Course: The Role of Motivational Orientation, Learning Strategies, Procrastination,
and Perceptions of Daily Hassles
Ronald L. Skidmore and Francis H. Osborne,
Morehead State University
This study examined
the practicality and reliability of using a select group of self-report
measures assessing motivational orientation, learning strategies, procrastination,
and perceptions of daily hassles to predict student engagement and relative
performance in a self-paced introductory psychology course. Research
has shown these factors to be associated with academic success and of
concern to instructors and students alike. Economical and reliable
surveys that permit effective assessment of these factors would be invaluable
for predicting of student course engagement and determining subsequent
intervention. A total of four surveys purporting to measure the constructs
listed above were chosen. A demographic survey was also administered.
The course utilized
a local area network of personal computers to administer surveys, unit
practice quizzes and mastery tests, course tutorials, and final examinations.
Students who agreed to participate in the study were administered the
surveys during the first three class periods of the semester. The course
was self-paced, with students determining their rate of engagement.
A criterion level of course points determined course completion. Data
were collected on 149 students, 122 of whom completed the course.
For students completing
the course, the degree of engagement was determined relevant to the
number of days to course completion. A median-split was used to determine
early-finish versus late-finish groups. Non-finishers comprised the
third group. Discriminant function analysis to discover and interpret
combinations of predictors determined that group membership could be
reliably predicted from the set of chosen surveys. Implications for
utilization of these surveys to predict student engagement and performance,
as well as instructor intervention, were discussed.
Unsuccessful Study Habits in Foreign
Language Courses
Phillip D. Bailey, University Of Central
Arkansas, and Anthony J. Onwuegbuzie, Howard University
Although some students
excel in learning a foreign language, many students fail to achieve
their desired levels of proficiency. In an attempt to understand this
phenomenon, researchers have investigated several factors that may affect
language learning.
Research has shown
that the most successful learners are those who use learning strategies
that tend to be the most optimal for second-language acquisition. Because
learning strategy use is a component of study habits, it is likely that
the latter would be related to foreign-language achievement. Indeed,
as Oxford (1989) noted, language learning strategy research has suffered
from an overemphasis on metacognitive and cognitive strategies, that
are admittedly very important, at the expense of other strategy types
that are also very useful (p. 2). Surprisingly, however, little is known
about which study habits distinguish successful from unsuccessful language
learners. This was the purpose of the present investigation.
Participants were
219 college students, from a variety of disciplinary backgrounds, who
were enrolled in Spanish, French, German, or Japanese classes. A canonical
discriminant analysis (F[6, 117], p < .0001; canonical R = .92) revealed
that, compared to their high-performing counterparts, students with
the lowest levels of foreign-language achievement tended to report that:
(1) they frequently include a lot of irrelevant or unimportant information
in their notes, (2) when they have difficulty with their assignments,
they do not seek help from their instructor, (3) they put their lecture
notes away after taking the test and never consult them again, (4) they
have to be in the mood before attempting to study, (5) they have a tendency
to doodle or daydream when they are trying to study, and (6) they do
not consult a dictionary concerning the meanings of words that they
do not understand. The implications of these findings were discussed.
Session
1.4 READING ACHIEVEMENT Riverside East
Chair:
Dennis C. Zuelke, Jacksonville State University
Effectiveness of the Alabama Reading
Initiative
Dana Lynn Key, The University Of Alabama
Research and reform
mandates in education confirmed that of the numerous problems besetting
education, those that concerned reading comprehension and retention
were among the most serious and significant. This study examined the
implications for higher academic success for students when classroom
teachers were trained in the research-based strategies taught in the
Alabama Reading Initiative training. Specifically, the study looked
at the following components that were integral for that training and
critical for implementation in the classroom: (1) reading in the content
area, (2) writing in the content area, (3) comprehension strategies,
and (3) reading and writing connection.
The study sought
to answer the following questions: (1) How can teachers trained in the
ARI better identify and intervene when students have difficulty with
reading and writing? and (2) What curriculum modifications and research-based
strategies work best to raise the academic success of students who have
a history of failure in school?
This study covered
approximately 15 months with 25-30 teacher participants. The researcher
was part of the ARI training team and served on the committee for revision
of the modules for ARI. The data were collected from: (1) field-notes,
(2) evaluation summaries, (3) interviews, and (4) document analysis
of student test scores. The study employed both quantitative and qualitative
methodology, and member checks, triangulation, and peer debriefing were
used to ensure credibility and validity. The themes that emerged were
related to: (1) the profound difference in test scores that the ARI
made for all students, (2) the need for additional inservice and training
for teachers, and (3) the evaluation of the program after it was in
place is essential. The findings suggested implications for teachers,
teacher educators, and curriculum coordinators.
Evaluation of Year 2 of the Alabama
Reading Initiative
Marcia R. O'Neal and Scott W. Snyder,
University of Alabama at Birmingham, and Mary W. Spor, University of
Alabama at Huntsville
The Alabama Reading
Initiative (ARI) is a statewide effort whose goal is 100% literacy for
public school students. The program targets beginning reading, expansion
of reading power, and intervention for struggling readers, and emphasizes
implementation of research-based reading instruction at participating
schools. The ARI model is unique in that it includes all students in
K-12, requires 85% faculty participation, as well as principal participation
and leadership in summer professional development, and emphasizes partnerships
with professional educators in institutions of higher education. ARI
was implemented in 16 schools in 1998-1999 and was expanded to include
81 schools in 1999-2000.
Evaluation of ARI
Year 2 addressed six questions: (1) To what extent are ARI schools
making progress toward 100% literacy? (2) Which ARI schools are making
progress toward 100% literacy and which are not? (3) What factors are
related to school outcomes? (4) Why are some ARI schools making more
progress than others? (5) To what extent are the elements of ARI reflected
in preservice teacher education programs throughout Alabama? and (6)
What ARI factors are related to change in preservice teacher education
programs?
Both achievement
and survey data were used to answer the evaluation questions. Among
the findings were the following: (1) improvements in Stanford 9 NCEs
for reading subtests averaged 1.05 for the original 16 schools and .28
for the 65 schools that began in 1999-2000, (2) ARI schools decreased
their population of "struggling readers" by as much as 10%
and increased their percentage of "grade-level readers" more
than non-ARI schools, (3) about 75% of ARI schools made at least small
gains on reading subtests, (4) factors differentiating higher-performing
from lower-performing ARI schools included principal leadership, hands-on
reading specialists, and deeply involved higher education partners;
and (5) higher education faculty reported changes in course content,
its incorporation of new reading standards into course syllabi, and
improved preservice teaching experiences.
Kentuckys School Report Card and Fourth-Grade Reading Scores
Beverly M. Klecker, Morehead State University
Reading, a fundamental
subject taught in elementary schools, is the key to subsequent learning.
In Kentucky, assessment of reading, with the school as the unit of analysis,
first occurs in the fourth grade. These scores are used to improve
the schools reading program. In 1999, a new Kentucky law required
that each district and public school produce and distribute school report
cards to the parents of each child. In addition to reporting the schools
scores on the Commonwealth Accountability Testing System (CATS), the
school report card presents information about the school. This exploratory,
descriptive study was designed to investigate relationships between
the elementary schools reading scores and information sent to
the parents via the schools report card.
The variables reported
on the school report card sent to parents are: (1) school size, (2)
CATS scores, (3) attendance, (4) retention, (5) teacher certification,
(6) teacher major, (7) teacher participation in professional development,
(8) teachers masters degree, (9) teaching, (10) per-pupil
expenditure, (11) pupil-teacher ratio, and (12) number of students with
parent attending teacher conference. Research reporting relationships
between some of these variables (e.g., school size, Holland & Gladden,
2001) and achievement was reviewed.
Fourth-grade reading
school-level Kentucky Core Content Tests (part of CATS) scores were
obtained from the Kentucky Department of Education. Schools with scores
in the top 10% and bottom 10% were selected for the study. School report
card information was also obtained from KDE for these schools (N=20).
Descriptive tables were prepared, and chi-square goodness-of-fit tests
were used to explore differences between variables.
A statistically
significant difference between schools with fourth-grade reading scores
in the top 10% and schools with scores in the bottom 10% was found with
the attendance data only.
Session
1.5 MENTORING NEW FACULTY IN HIGHER EDUCATION (Symposium) Riverside
West
Organizer:
Gypsy A. Abbott, University of Alabama at Birmingham
Promoting Publishing Through Mentoring
Karen Dahle and Betty Higdon, University of Alabama at Birmingham
Building A Sense Of Community Through Mentoring
Janice Patterson, University of Alabama at Birmingham
Defining The Mentoring Relationship
Loucrecia Collins, University of Alabama at Birmingham
Lessons Learned
Mary Nix, University of Alabama at Birmingham
Retention of new
faculty in higher education has been a topic of discussion for the last
two decades. Although many mentoring programs have been described, few
appeared to be as comprehensive as was desired in the UAB School of
Education. Thus, the mentoring program developed addressed the goal
of fostering and promoting the development of the skills necessary for
new faculty members to be successful in obtaining tenure.
In this symposium,
the results of the innovative mentoring program for new faculty in the
UAB School of Education were described. This mentoring program was based
on a review of the literature regarding successful practices in mentoring
in higher education. Factors such as regular meeting, specific goals,
and clear expectations of mentors and mentees were included in the plan.
In addition, the issue of "What is in it for me?, or "Just
one more thing to do" was addressed through the Dean of the School
of Education providing a stipend for mentors that could be used for
travel or in other needed ways. It was interesting that the majority
of mentors indicated that they did not wish to use the stipend available.
The mentors state, however, that the fact that the project was strongly
supported by the dean's office had a positive effect on their attitudes
toward participation.
In this program,
an innovative dimension was added. A research design for studying the
process of mentoring that was occurring was developed. Mentees and mentors
kept field notes regarding their experiences in the areas of expectations,
accomplishments, building relationships, building a sense of community,
and publishing. The research design specified that the field notes from
the actual mentoring process would be analyzed and that the results
would be submitted for publication and presentation. Data were collected
between January 2001 and May 2001. These data were analyzed using qualitative
methodology based on phenomenology. The intent was to capture and describe
the experiences of mentees and mentors as they participated in the program.
This approach to
mentoring was unique in that new faculty are mentored through the process
of gathering and analyzing data, as well as submitting the data for
presentation and publication. Each of the papers comprising this symposium
addressed the issues identified in the research design. The papers
presented findings from the implementation of this program, as well
as lessons learned.
10:30 A.M. - 11:20 A.M.
Session 2.1 TEACHING PRACTICE Salon A
Chair: Mary Nix, University of Alabama
at Birmingham
Are Teacher Perceptions
Aligned with Actual Classroom Observations Involving Cooperative Learning
Activities in School Reform Models?
Allison P. Potter, The University of
Memphis
The purpose of
this study was to examine the differences between teacher perceptions
of their instructional method in the classroom and the method of instruction
actually observed. In a study involving an urban school in the United
States that was in the process of implementing cooperative learning
methods in the classroom, it was noted that the struggles teachers at
the school faced when trying to implement a teaching method different
than what they believed (or had been trained) in was reflected in the
quality of the students' activities in the classroom. Another study
noted that classroom observations of teachers involved in implementation
of new student-centered methods of teaching revealed that teachers partly
continue to use their old direct instruction methods in the classroom.
Teachers may think that they are acting more as a facilitator in guiding
student-centered activities when, in fact, actual observations do not
reflect this.
This present study
addressed two key questions: (1) Are there differences between observed
classroom activities and teacher reported classroom activities of cooperative
learning? and (2) Also, if there are differences, what are some of
the reasons for the differences? Teacher responses (N=455) to the item,
"Students in my class spend much of their time working in cooperative
learning teams," were taken from the School Restructuring Teacher
Questionnaire© instrument. This was compared with the amount of cooperative/collaborative
learning instructional orientation observed using the School Observation
Measure Data Summary©. Teacher comments from Teacher Focus Group summaries
were also examined. The findings showed that while 77% of the teachers
agreed that students in their classroom spent much of their time working
in cooperative learning groups, it was only observed 49% of the time.
One key implication of this study was for teacher training and/or mentoring
in instructional methods before and during the implementation process.
Preservice Teachers'
Perspectives Concerning Constructivist Experiences in Content Area and
Professional Education Courses
Timothy L. Carter and Rebecca Shopfner,
Arkansas Tech University
The constructivist
view of learning has received increased positive emphasis within the
last two decades in education (e.g., Brandt & Perkins, 2000; Mayer,
1998). However, Posner, Strike, Hewson, and Gertzog's (1982) and Strike
and Posner's (1992) research has suggested that for this new conceptual
understanding of learning to be fully accepted and implemented the stakeholders
involved must first experience the four critical steps of conceptual
change.
Based on their
conceptual change model, the present study examined the perspectives
of preservice teachers pertaining to the use of constructivist methodologies
in their content area courses versus a six-hour professional education
course. The sample consisted of 17 preservice secondary teachers from
a state university in a rural town in northwestern Arkansas. Data were
collected at the beginning of a scheduled class period using two 10-question
Likert surveys, based on Beller's (1998) work, with responses ranging
from "1" meaning "Never" to "9" meaning
"Always." On each survey, Likert statements were identical
in content. One survey queried students about their "constructivist"
experiences prior to this professional education course, and the other
survey queried students about their "constructivist" experiences
during the course. Each of the 10 items was statistically compared
from the two surveys using a paired samples t‑test with the alpha
level set at .05.
Results indicated
that scores for each of the 10 items were statistically significantly
different (p < .05). The results suggested that students may not
be experiencing ample opportunities throughout their teacher preparation
to experience conceptual change regarding their views of learning.
By not providing these experiences, future educators may not experience
the final critical step of the conceptual change model, and educational
change may not be realized as readily.
Cooperative Learning: A Method for Teaching
Anissa Harris, University of Louisiana
at Monroe
Pursued by parents,
teachers, and employers across the world, cooperation is a richly valued
commodity in 21st century homes, schools, and businesses. Many educators,
therefore, have adjusted to the social aspect of learning and have applied
cooperative learning strategies, at least in principle, to classroom
instruction (Johnson, Johnson, & Smith, 1998b). Heralded by educational
researchers as an essential tool for effective teaching, cooperative
learning has fast become common in the classroom (Slavin, 1999).
The purpose of
this review was to investigate the components of cooperative learning
and discuss variations in strategies and effectiveness from a theoretical
perspective by analyzing current publications from the cornerstone theorists
and implementers of this teaching strategy. The model's application
to students with learning difficulties and students with high achievement
was discussed in a section on implementation and evaluation of the model
where the researcher relates the perspective of teachers and several
studies on the quality use of cooperative learning in the classroom.
Thus, this review concentrated on the current implementation of cooperative
learning at the elementary, secondary, and college levels and discussed
the effectiveness, appropriateness to content area, application to students
with special needs, benefits, and variations of the strategies in the
hope that readers could develop a better understanding of the appropriate
use of this model.
Session 2.2 POLICY Salon B
Chair:
Larry G. Daniel, University of North Florida
Educational Equity in Alabama: What We Learned from Report Card 2000
Marie Miller‑Whitehead, Tennessee
Valley Educators for Excellence
The study examined
the Year 2000 Alabama State Report Card indicators to identify predictors
for student academic achievement at both the district and school level
for the 128 school districts and 1272 public schools in Alabama to provide
local, state, and federal agencies with information for making decisions
about schools. The two measures for student achievement used in the
analysis, performance grade and SAT average, were provided on the state
report card for each school district and school.
Variables included
in the analysis were system type (city or county); number of students;
percentage of students on free and reduced meals; percentage of average
daily attendance, per pupil expenditure; dropout percentages from 1999;
school district, local, state, and federal revenues; and percentage
of system and school employees with bachelor's, master's, and six-year
doctoral licensure.
Results of hierarchical
regression models indicated that for both school districts and schools,
poverty had a negative effect on both SAT averages and performance grades.
Models were more powerful for predicting SAT averages than performance
grades, but results indicated that city school districts were more likely
to have both higher SAT averages and performance grades than were county
districts, and for both city and county school districts the percent
of AA administrative personnel and percent of local revenue had a statistically
significant positive effect on student achievement. City districts
had significantly higher percentages of local funding than county districts.
At the school level,
higher enrollment had a negative effect on student achievement, while
higher percentage average daily attendance and higher percentage of
faculty with the master's degree had a significant positive effect on
student achievement.
Conclusions were that higher percentages of local funding
and higher percentages of administrative licensures at the district
level were most highly correlated to higher student SAT averages and
performance grades.
Comparing School Finance Equity Among
Mid‑South States
Mary Hughes and Gary W. Ritter, University
of Arkansas
As the Arkansas
legislature and Department of Education wrestle with the recent court
order to modify the state's system of funding schools, it is important
to consider school funding equity in Arkansas and the other states in
the mid-south: Alabama, Kentucky, Louisiana, Mississippi, and Tennessee.
The challenge in
doing comparative analyses among states with regard to school finance
equity revolves around different methods and categories in reporting
school finance data. However, this problem is solved to some extent
by the National Center for Education Statistics, that publishes annually
the Common Core of Data (or CCD) that provides detailed data (including
funding data) for all schools, districts, and states in the United States.
This paper employed
standard measures of school finance equity to describe and compare the
level of school funding equity for each of the mid-south states throughout
the 1990s.
Influence of School Board Member on
State Legislation
W. Keith Christy and Larry McNeal, University
of Arkansas at Little Rock
A survey of Arkansas
school board members was conducted from July through September 2000.
The survey of 1801 school board members served as a major purpose to
identify specific legislative issues that the Arkansas School Boards
Association would include in its legislative agenda for the 2001 legislative
session.
The results of
the study indicated that the greatest concerns centered on: (1) financial
issues at the state and federal levels, (2) significant concerns about
education at the local level, (3) policy issues at the state and federal
level, and (4) board member involvement in state and federal policy
making.
The survey was
conducted in two parts: an individual response and a composite board
of education response. The survey response of the boards was 71%, and
the individual response rate was 61%.
The data revealed
that the greatest concern to local school boards and their members was
finance related in that local school boards as collective bodies believed
that receiving adequate funds and being able to pay competitive salaries
were their greatest immediate concerns. Another indicator to support
funding as an important issue was the individual board members
identifying the most significant long-term challenges facing school
boards as that of an insufficient investment at the local level. Tied
to this insufficient funding support was the challenge of hiring and
retaining teachers inasmuch as the Arkansas salaries are below national
and regional averages.
The significance
of this research was the outcome of the work of the 2001 legislative
session. Governor Huckabee placed educational funding and, specifically,
a raise of teacher salaries, as the foremost item to his legislative
agenda. The legislature responded with a significant increase of funding
directed at an increase of $3,000 to the base salary of teachers to
occur over the next two years.
The results of
this survey were the cornerstone of setting the legislative agenda of
the Arkansas School Boards Association. The actions of the 2001 Arkansas
Legislature indicated a positive response to the views of Arkansas school
board members.
Session 2.3 GIFTED EDUCATION Salon C
Chair: Jane Nell Luster, Louisiana State
University
Moral Reasoning, Attributional Complexity,
and Social Status of Gifted Children
Antony D. Norman, Western Kentucky University
Although heightened
emotional and moral sensitivity is one of the most common characteristics
attributed to the gifted, very little research has been conducted in
this area. This study examined the relationships among moral reasoning,
attributional complexity, and social status in gifted children.
Data were collected
on 300 gifted children entering 7th through 12th grades who attended
two summer programs for the gifted. To measure moral reasoning ability,
the Defining Issues Test (DIT) was administered. To measure attributional
complexity, the preference for complex rather than simple explanations
for events and behavior, the Attributional Complexity Scale was administered.
Measures of gifted students' social status were obtained by using two
peer status instruments, peer ratings, and peer nominations. Based
on these vehicles, students were classified as popular, neglected, rejected,
or average.
Findings regarding
the moral reasoning ability of these gifted children compared to age
norms provided in the DIT manual were revealed. Further, findings regarding
relationships among moral reasoning ability, attributional complexity,
and social status were revealed and discussed. The presentation concluded
with a discussion of implications for educating gifted children.
What I Hate About Being Gifted
Eileen Talento‑Miller, Mississippi
State University
The word gifted
could be used to describe any birthday girl or boy who is opening a
present. The experience of intellectual giftedness is analogous in that
the gifts at times may induce the same kind of thrill that comes from
opening a much wanted toy, while at other times the gifts may produce
the same type of chagrin that comes from discovering that one has received
socks. Current research was reviewed that described the negative aspects
of giftedness from the point of view of participants who have been identified
as gifted. Among the topics examined were the issues of perfectionism,
expectations of others, social adjustment, and underachievement, as
well as the differences in the difficulties of gifted children versus
gifted adults, and the differences found among moderately
gifted individuals versus highly gifted individuals. The
implications for the need for counseling tailored to the special needs
of the gifted population, as well as the efficacy of different types
of special programming in addressing these concerns, were also addressed.
Multiyear Analysis of Gifted Education Programming for Disadvantaged
Students
Deborah J. Abell, Morehead State University
Students who come
from economically disadvantaged families often perform poorly on the
standardized tests used to identify gifted students. A need exists to
establish a method of identifying economically disadvantaged gifted
students that does not penalize them because of poor performance on
standardized norm-referenced tests.
Affluent white
students consistently score higher on traditional norm-referenced tests
that are used to make gifted education placement decisions (Barstow
& Baldwin, 1988). Research indicates that giftedness is evenly distributed
across race, gender, and ethnic groups (Eby & Smutney, 1990; Smith,
Le Rose, & Clasen, 1991). Are we to believe that giftedness is
not evenly distributed across socioeconomic status? Gifted economically
disadvantaged students represent an untapped potential for excellence
in school systems across the nation (Maker, 1989; Patton, Prillaman,
& VanTassel-Baska, 1990; Richert, 1987).
The education coordinator
for gifted and talented students at each school was surveyed to obtain
data. The survey included information on students identified for gifted
programming categorized by sex, qualification for free/reduced lunch,
race, and presence of disability.
The study provided
chi-square and descriptive statistical analyses of the percentage of
students identified for gifted education programs who participated in
the federal free/reduced lunch program, including information regarding
sex, race, and presence of disability. The subjects were 2000 students
enrolled in three middle schools. Significantly more students who are
identified as gifted qualify for free/reduced lunch in 2001 compared
to the beginning of the program.
The conclusion
reached was that teachers who have received specific training in the
identification of these hard-to-identify populations were better able
to identify economically disadvantaged gifted students after training,
and the percentages of economically disadvantaged students identified
as gifted have increased significantly.
Session 2.4 MATH EDUCATION Riverside East
Chair: Julie A. Holmes, Louisiana Tech University/Lincoln
Parish (Louisiana) Schools
Effect of Gender, Achievement in Mathematics,
and Grade Level on Attitudes Toward Mathematics
Martha Tapia, Berry College, and George
E. Marsh II, The University of Alabama
The effects of
gender, math achievement, and grade level on attitudes toward mathematics
were examined by use of an inventory, Attitudes Toward Mathematics Instrument.
Subjects were 803 bilingual, middle and high school students. The data
were analyzed using a multivariate factorial model with four factors
of Mathematics Attitudes as dependent variables (self-confidence, value,
motivation, and enjoyment of mathematics) and three independent variables
(gender, math achievement, and grade level). A two-way significant interaction
of achievement by grade level was found. The interaction was found
to be significant for value, motivation, and enjoyment of mathematics
at all grade levels. "A" students scored higher than all
other students on the three factors from 7th through 10th grades and
in motivation in students in 11th and 12th grades. For value, failing
students were lowest in 7th through 10th grades. A similar relationship
of letter grade to motivation was found in the hierarchy for "B
to D" students in 7th and 8th grades. For enjoyment, failing students
were lowest in 7th and 8th grades, B and C students scored higher than
D and F students in 9th and 10th grades, and A and B students were highest
in 11th and 12th grades.
The Relationship
Between Social Promotion in the Middle School and Academic Achievement
in a High School Math Class
Lana M. Page and Patrick Kariuki, Milligan
College
The Third International
Mathematics and Science Study (TIMSS) indicated that national (U.S.)
math scores were below international averages. Social promotion was
identified as one possible factor contributing to poor mathematical
achievement. No conclusive evidence existed to support or refute the
practice of social promotion. Further study was needed to determine
its effectiveness. Therefore, the purpose of this study was to determine
the relationship between social promotion in the middle school and academic
achievement in the high school math class.
Students permanent
records were reviewed to determine which students had been promoted
without mastery in middle school. The sample consisted of 30 seniors
from a northeastern Tennessee high school who were promoted without
mastery in the middle school. Their academic achievement in the high
school math class was recorded. The relationship between social promotion
and mathematical academic achievement was analyzed using Pearson product
moment correlation. Similarly, the relationship between math academic
achievement and overall high school academic achievement was analyzed
using the Pearson product moment correlation. The difference in male
and female mathematical academic achievement was analyzed using an independent
t-test. Also, the difference between the number of times a student was
promoted in the middle school was analyzed using t-test for paired sample
means.
The results indicated
a significant negative correlation between social promotion and high
school math academic achievement. A strong correlation existed between
math academic achievement and overall academic achievement at the high
school level. There was no significant difference between the mathematical
academic achievement of males and females. Also, no significant difference
was found between the number of times a student was promoted in middle
school and high school math achievement. The study suggested that students
who have been socially promoted in middle school performed poorly in
high school math classes.
A Follow-Up Study of Students Eligible
for a Gifted Math Program
Betty K. Wood, University of Arkansas
at Little Rock
This follow-up study of students who were
eligible to participate in the Gifted Math Program (GMP) at the University
of Arkansas at Little Rock compared participants and non-participants
in several areas. Among the areas were: (1) quantitative scores on
ACT/SAT, (2) college major/career choice, and (3) personal benefits
of the program.
Studies of programs for gifted and talented
students show that there are benefits to special programs for gifted
students. Studies of highly intelligent children contribute to our
understanding of the many forms of giftedness and the type of intervention
necessary to develop high-level performance. These students need times
when they can experience the satisfaction and joy of significant learning.
Of the 2697 students
who were eligible for the GMP from 1984-1989, 1000 names were randomly
selected and questionnaire packets were sent to them. Of the 100 people
responding to the questionnaire, 50% had participated in the GMP, 50%
had not participated, 47% were males, 53% were females, 87% were Caucasian,
7% were African American, and 4% classified themselves as Other. Nine
female and five male participants, one female and four male nonparticipants,
and nine parents were interviewed on the telephone. Both quantitative
analysis and qualitative analysis were used to describe the results.
Session
2.5 STATISTICS Riverside West
Chair: Gail Weems, The University of Memphis
Methods for Correctly
Performing ANCOVA with Multilevel Analysis When the Homogeneity of Regression
Assumption is Not Met
J. Kyle Roberts, University of North
Texas
Although the ANCOVA
method has become widely used and accepted in modern statistical applications,
Henson (1999) has noted that, continually, researchers neglect to check
the assumption of homogeneity of regression and incorrectly model a
compensatory rivalry between groups. This often happens because researchers
are including covariates in a model when testing for differences between
intact groups rather than completely randomized groups. In many occasions,
covariates need to be included in the OVA model to test for mean differences,
but methods for controlling for differences in regression weights are
either not available to researchers or are not utilized. While normal
OVA methods cannot control for these differences, recent developments
in statistics and technology have enabled researchers to model individual
(rather than collective) regression coefficients for intact groups while
still testing for differences on the primary dependent variable in the
OVA model.
The purpose of
this paper was to show the utility of modeling random slope coefficients
in the ANCOVA model through multilevel and hierarchical linear modeling
(MLM and HLM). Utilizing a heuristic dataset that violated the homogeneity
of regression assumption, this paper illustrated multilevel procedures
with both SAS and MLwiN software packages. The presentation, however,
illustrated just the MLwiN software package. Because multilevel modeling
is a statistical procedure that is not readily known to most researchers,
methods for conducting multilevel procedures were illustrated during
the presentation with the MLwiN software package. Resources for conducting
multilevel analysis were also distributed at the presentation. Graphing
displays also showed exactly what was happening with the data by graphing
residuals of the regression coefficients and then modeling differences
in these coefficients.
Regression Diagnostics in Educational Research
Jesus Tanguma, University of Houston
at Clear Lake
Linear regression models are commonly used in educational
research settings to help explain and predict subjects' performance.
However, blindly applying a regression model without regard to its assumptions
and goodness of fit may lead to errors in inference. Thus, it is imperative
that researchers graphically and mathematically scrutinize their data
before computing any statistics (e.g., applying a regression model).
A relatively new technique that can assist the researcher identify influential
data points is regression diagnostics.
Six commonly used diagnostics procedures (partial regression
plots, the hat matrix, studentized residuals, DFITSi, Cook's Di and
DFBETASij) for identifying influential data points were illustrated
by means of hypothetical examples. Also, where appropriate, cutoff values
were suggested.
Partial regression
plots are the multivariate analog of the bivariate scatter plots typically
used in simple linear regression. However, the variables plotted in
the partial regression plots are residual variables. The hat elements
(hii) are indicative of the distance from Xi to the mean. Thus, the
larger the farther Xi is from the mean , the larger the hi. Although
the residuals (ei) are the primary means for detecting outliers, they
may have substantially different variances. Thus, it is important to
consider the magnitude of each ei relative to its standard deviation.
The ratio of ei to s{ ei }is called the studentized residual. DFITSi
is a measure that is affected both by residuals and extreme values.
That is, any observation with a high hi or low ei (or vice versa) will
be signaled by DFITSi. Cook's distance measures the influence of the
ith case on all fitted values. Thus, if the case with the largest Cook
value were removed, the estimates of the coefficients would change more
than for any other case. DFBETASij is a measure of how individual coefficients
are affected when a case is omitted.
Reporting Practice and Use of Exploratory
Factor Analyses in Educational Research Journals
Robin K. Henson, University of North
Texas, and Robert M. Capraro and Mary Margaret Capraro, Texas A&M
University
It is often not
understood that implicit within all classical parametric analyses is
a principal components analysis. This truism suggests the importance
of factor analysis implicitly within statistics and explicitly as a
method. The goal of factor analysis itself is typically parsimony and
is often used to explain a larger set of j measured variables with a
smaller set of k latent constructs. These more parsimonious constructs
can be used as variables in subsequent analyses and are typically viewed
as causing the responses to the observed variables. Thanks to the advent
of technology, factor analysis is now frequently employed.
Given the proliferation
of factor analysis applications in the literature, the purpose of the
present paper was to examine the utilization of factor analysis in current
published research. Notwithstanding ease of analysis because of computers,
the appropriate use of factor analysis requires a series of thoughtful
researcher judgments. These judgments directly impact results and interpretations.
Specifically, the
presenters examined several education journals and noted across studies
(1) the decisions made while conducting exploratory factor analyses
and (2) the information reported from the analyses. Accordingly, the
paper addressed the current status of factor analytic decisions and
reporting practices in education journals. The study also replicated
a similar study that centered more on psychology journals.
Results indicated
egregious errors of commission and omission regarding factor analysis
use and interpretation. Examples of errors included poor strategies
for determining the number of factors to retain and failure to report
and interpret factor structure coefficients when using an oblique rotation.
At times, the extraction method and rotation strategy were not noted.
This paper included in discussion other errors of usage and reporting
and presented recommendations for the improved use of factor analysis
in educational research.
11:30 A.M. - 12:20 P.M.
Session 3.1 AT-RISK CHILDREN Salon A
Chair: Jean Newman Clark, University
of South Alabama
The Validity and Reliability of the
Adult-Adolescent Parenting Inventory II
Nicola A. Conners, Leanne Whiteside-Mansell,
and Angela L. White, University of Arkansas for Medical Sciences
The ability to
accurately assess the child-rearing attitudes of parents or other individuals
working with children is important to the success of child abuse prevention
efforts. The purpose of this study was to examine the validity and
reliability of the Adult-Adolescent Parenting Inventory II (AAPI-II)
with low-income, rural parents. The AAPI-II is a 40-item questionnaire
designed to assess the child-rearing attitudes of adolescents and adults,
including parents, prospective parents, and individuals who work with
children. The questionnaire was designed to identify attitudes and
beliefs consistent with those of known child abusers, and thus provided
an index of risk for abuse or neglect. Information on the reliability
and validity of the AAPI was limited, and the appropriateness of the
questionnaire for certain populations was unknown.
The sample for
this study included 170 low-income parents whose preschool children
were enrolled in Head Start programs in rural Arkansas and who were
participants in the Starting Early Starting Smart research study. The
AAPI-II was administered during a home interview that also included
other assessments of parenting style and behavior.
Alpha reliability
coefficients were computed for the full scale and each of the five AAPI-II
subscales for the full sample, and separately for parents with different
levels of education. The overall alpha was .86 for the full sample,
with subscales ranging from .65 to .82. Similar results were found
for parents with and without college education. Confirmatory factor
analysis was performed and coefficient H was computed, and the results
offer support for the factor structure proposed by the developer. Relationships
between the AAPI-II scales and theoretically-related measures of parenting
style and behavior were examined, and significant correlations were
found, ranging in size from moderate (.23) to strong (.51). Overall,
findings offered support for the use of the AAPI-II with low-income,
rural parents.
The Validity and Reliability of the
Parenting Styles Typology
Leanne Whiteside‑Mansell, Nicola
A. Conners, and Danya Lee Johnson, University of Arkansas for Medical
Science
Developmental psychologists
are almost in universal agreement that children from preschool to adolescents
fair better when raised by authoritative parents than children raised
by parents with other parenting styles. However, classifying a parents
style is difficult as few cost-efficient measures exist, particularly
for the preschool child.
The purpose of
this study was to examine the validity and reliability of a paper assessment
of parenting style developed by Greenberger and Goldberg (1988) in a
sample of low-income, rural parents of preschoolers. This study examined
two surveys to assess parental types of discipline (Harsh Control, Firm/Responsive
Control, and Lax Control) and demands for maturity (independence, self-control,
prosocial). The resulting summative scores and the parenting style
classifications were investigated.
The sample for
this study included 199 low-income parents whose preschool children
were enrolled in Head Start programs in rural Arkansas and who were
participants in the Starting Early Starting Smart research study. The
data were collected during a home interview that also included other
assessments of parenting style and behavior. Seventy-two percent of
families were classified into permissive (41%), authoritative (20%),
authoritarian (26%), and a mixed category (30%).
Alpha reliability
coefficients were computed for the summary scores with values ranging
from .63 to .88. Reliability estimates were computed from 42 tests-retests
(two-week interval), and the reliability coefficient H was computed
(using CFA).Confirmatory factor analysis was performed, and support
for the factor structure proposed by the developer and cautions were
discussed.
Support for the
validity of the parenting scales and style classifications were examined
using theoretically related measures of parenting attitudes, behavior,
and family characteristics. Correlation coefficients ranged from .15
to .54 in predicted patterns. Overall, findings offered support for
the use of the summative scores and limited support for parenting style
classification.
Attributions Toward Violence of Male
Juvenile Delinquents: A Concurrent Mixed‑Methodological Analysis
Christine E. Daley, Muscogee County
School District, and Anthony J. Onwuegbuzie, Howard University
Violence among
youth has reached epidemic proportions. Despite considerable research,
however, we still do not understand why adolescents become involved
in violent acts. Thus, this study investigated male juvenile delinquents'
causal attributions they make for others' behavior, and the salient
pieces of information they utilize in arriving at their attributions.
Participants were 82 male juvenile offenders, selected via an a priori
power analysis, who were drawn randomly from the population of juveniles
incarcerated at a correctional facilities located in a large southeastern
state.
A six-stage, concurrent,
mixed-methodological analysis, utilizing both qualitative and quantitative
data-analytic techniques, revealed that the juvenile offenders committed
violent attributional errors nearly 53% of the time. Black juvenile
offenders were more likely to commit violence attributional errors than
were their white counterparts. Also, a positive relationship was found
between the number of prior arrests and the number of violence attributional
errors. A phenomenological analysis revealed the following seven themes
that arose from juveniles' reasons for their causal attributions: self-control,
violation of rights, provocation, irresponsibility, poor judgment, fate,
and conflict resolution. A combination of these themes was related to
age, ethnicity, and number of prior arrests. An exploratory factor analysis
revealed that the seven themes fell into four meta-themes. Finally,
an ipsative/cluster analysis identified three profiles of delinquents
based on their violence attribution reasons. Implications were discussed.
Session 3.2 TECHNOLOGY Salon C
Chair: Larry R. Dickerson, University of
Arkansas at Little Rock
On‑Line Teaching: A Framework
for Success
Candace H. Lacey, Barry University,
and Amany Saleh, Arkansas State University
On-line instruction
is rapidly gaining popularity at college and on campuses throughout
the world. Once the sole niche of store-front diplols, advances in technology,
as well as student demand, have made everyone sit up and take notice.
More and more university administrators are requiring departments to
put courses, and in some cases entire programs, on-line. The faculty
members are on the front line of this technology invasion and the faculty
members must face the daily challenges of a delivery system that does
not always provide what it promises.
Both of the presenters have had extensive
experience in teaching on-line courses. Grounded in this experience
base, the presenters proposed that a framework needs to be considered
when making decisions regarding the use of on-line courses. Central
to this framework were five areas for consideration: (1) what courses
are appropriate for on-line delivery, (2) to what extent should the
technology be used to support classroom teaching, (3) what training
is required/available for the instructor, (4) what technical support
is available, and (5) what level of technology proficiency should students
possess to enroll in an on-line class.
Experience with
teaching students as far away as Indonesia and as close as the dorm
across the street has led the presenters to believe that there is indeed
a place for on-line technology in the higher education classroom. However,
these decisions should be guided by a framework that provides both knowledge
and understanding.
Integrating Four
Courses into a Twelve-Credit-Hour Block of Instruction in an On-Line
Format as Part of a Master's Degree Program in Educational Leadership
Jack J. Klotz, Warren G. Ortloff, and
Thelma J. Roberson, The University of Southern Mississippi
This presentation
detailed specific strategies on how to reformat traditional course work
into an integrated block of instruction for on-line delivery. Specifics
were provided detailing sequential steps followed by a team of professors
working together to replicate the instructional components associated
with traditional delivery methodologies in a Master's Program in Educational
Leadership. Information was presented regarding: (1) how four traditional
courses were integrated into one block of instruction to be delivered
over the Fall and Spring semester, (2) the specific training and support
needs of professors charged with such delivery, (3) how to conduct planning
meetings, (4) how to work with Continuing Education and Technology departments,
(5) how to identify objectives and activities that lend themselves to
the on-line environment and strategies to deal effectively with those
areas that are best addressed on-site, (6) how to select the most appropriate
technology to support the identified objectives, (7) suggested strategies
for evaluation of program design and delivery, and (8) a comparison
of student performance of students participating in the on-line format
with those participating in an on-site delivery format.
Confronting Design Problems in Developing
On-Line Courses in Higher Education
Thelma J. Roberson and Jack Klotz, The
University of Southern Mississippi
This paper presented
ideas and viable solutions to problems that may arise when developing
and implementing on-line courses. The authors described their personal
experiences with developing two sections of a team-taught, on-line course
including the problems that they encountered and the solutions that
they discovered. Issues addressed in this paper included: (1) training
and support needs of students and professors, (2) problems with using
AOL, (3) differences in synchronous and asynchronous environments, (4)
selection of technological components that fit the objectives of the
course, (5) syllabus development and how to trouble-shoot when problems
arise, (6) overcoming technology problems, (7) time zone considerations,
(8) international server problems, and (9) dealing with firewall protection.
The paper also
provided student reflections regarding the students positive and
negative reactions to this on-line experience. Former students were
invited to participate in the presentation of this paper via an Internet
link, that made it possible for the audience to interact with students
and ask questions regarding their impression of this delivery option.
Session 3.3 GRADUATE STUDENT LUNCHEON Salon D
Chair:
Jennifer Good, Auburn University
The Graduate Student Luncheon is sponsored by the Graduate
Student Advisory Committee, and is open to all graduate students registered
for the annual meeting.
12:30 P.M. - 1:20 P.M.
Session 4.1 TECHNOLOGY Salon A
Chair: Bobby J. Franklin, Louisiana Department
of Education
Technology Integration by Teachers,
Student Teachers, and Teacher Education Faculty in Alabama
Scott W. Snyder, Center for Educational
Accountability, UAB; Stevie Ash and Shannon Parks, Alabama State Department
of Education; and Feng Sun, Center for Educational Accountability
Surveys of first-year
teachers, experienced teachers, student teachers, cooperating teachers,
and teacher education faculty were conducted as part of the PT3 Catalyst
grant awarded to the Alabama State Department of Education. The purposes
of the surveys were to describe the baseline status of: (1) teachers
perceptions of their technology competencies, (2) student teacher competencies
in technology, and (3) the extent to which teacher education faculty
implement training in integrating technology within core courses. The
surveys of teachers and student teachers concerned perceptions of competence
in implementing ISTE/NETS standards. Surveys of cooperating teachers
concerned perceptions of the competence of the student teachers on the
technology competencies. Surveys of teacher education faculty concerned
the nature and extent to which standards are modeled, taught, and assessed
as part of core courses.
Survey sampling
involved a stratified random sample of teachers (1000 first-year teachers
and 500 experienced teachers), 20 pairs of student teacher/cooperating
teacher surveys distributed to each teacher education institution (600
total), and 20 faculty surveys sent to each teacher education institution
to be distributed to faculty who taught core courses during the fall
semester (600 total). Response rates for teacher surveys were approximately
25%. Rates for student teachers and higher education faculty cannot
be directly determined because of variations in numbers of student teacher
pairs and faculty within institution.
Results suggested
areas of consensus across respondent groups in terms of strengths and
needs. Survey results have been used as a part of efforts within Alabama
to establish technology integration expectations for graduates of teacher
education programs.
Getting it Together: Using Technology
as a Tool to Enhance Teaching and Learning
Linda F. Cornelious, Mississippi State
University
Technology has
entered the classroom today. No one has doubted that technology has
and will continue to play a role in enhancing teaching and learning
in the educational process. The question is no longer "will"
educators use technology, the question is now "how" will educators
use technology. Many schools have purchased software that includes
suites for computer labs, while several others have purchased only desktop
publishing software for use in higher-level courses. However, the key
word is "purchased." The question remains, How is this software
being used and who is using it? Now that schools have the capabilities
for using technology, are they capable of using it? The purpose of
this paper was to review the literature on implementing technology in
schools to enhance teaching and learning problems hampering teachers
from implementing technology into lesson plans, formulating technology
action plans, and needed research.
Although the appropriate
role of technology in schools has yet to be clearly defined, there are
basic questions to be answered when considering the use of technology
in a school system. Should computers and technology be limited to the
computer lab? Should all instructors be required to implement technology
into their daily lesson plans? When and where will teachers receive
training? These questions, among others, must be answered before schools
or districts can fully embrace the technology revolution.
This paper explored
implementing technology into the core curriculum, while using software
suites and desktop publishing to enhance the teaching and learning process.
The authors suggested how research could be used to assess the impact
that the use of technology has made on student achievement.
The Use of Technology by Teacher Education
Faculty for Problem Solving and Higher Order Thinking
Carol A. Brown, East Carolina University
Current research suggests that instructional computing
be imbedded within curriculum areas for math, science, social studies,
and language arts. No longer is the integration of computers an isolated
skill separate from the pedagogical courses for preservice teachers.
This study used self‑reported data from teacher education faculty
to determine the relationship between personal knowledge levels for
computers, use of computers within course activities, and familiarity
with professional organizations such as the International Society for
Technology in Education (ISTE).
ISTE standards
for teachers were used to generate survey items sent to teacher education
institutions in Arkansas. Cross tabulation and two‑way chi‑square
tests were used to determine relationships among demographic variables
and technology utilization. Pearson correlation coefficients were used
as an index to determine the strength and direction of relationships
among the reported scores for use of strategies for higher‑level
thinking and software applications such as word processing, database,
and spreadsheets.
Of the 125 Arkansas
methods faculty who responded to the survey, only 42 indicated familiarity
with ISTE. Faculty reported a frequent use of word processing for special
projects, and the use of the Internet for open‑ended problem solving
and for gathering information on the teaching profession. There was
infrequent use of database and spreadsheet applications for problem
solving and higher-level thinking skills.
Based on these
outcomes, it was recommended that faculty evaluation forms include assessment
of teaching strategies that use extended activities for higher-level
learning, as well as data manipulation. Instruction should also include
extended activities for organizing information, drawing conclusions,
and making predictions. Database, spreadsheet, and Internet resources
would provide the tools needed for the complex activities recommended
for problem solving and the transfer of learning.
Session
4.2 THE IMPACT OF STATE TESTING ON STUDENT PSYCHOLOGICAL WELL-BEING
AND ACHIEVEMENT (Symposium) Salon B
Organizer:
Sean W. Mulvenon, University of Arkansas
Parent's Involvement and Perceptions
of Standardized Testing: How Does it Affect Student Achievement
Monica S. Zozone, University of Arkansas
Teachers Perceptions of Standardized
Testing: Implications for Student Performance
Joannie Connors, University of Arkansas
Standardized Testing: Perceptions of
Counselors and Principals
Antionette Thorn, University of Arkansas
Students Perceptions of Standardized
Testing and Achievement: What are the Relationships?
Denise Lenares, University of Arkansas
President George
W. Bush signed legislation that mandates the standardized testing of
all students in grades 3 - 8. This expanded testing initiative is occurring
at a time when the psychological impact of standardized testing on students
is also being questioned by parents and teachers groups.
Numerous accounts of students demonstrating high levels of physical
and emotional anxiety over standardized testing have been provided in
reputable national journals such as Newsweek or Time Magazine. The anecdotal
cases provided in these journals do not provide an in-depth examination
of the actual impact of standardized testing on students.
The purpose of
this symposium was to present five manuscripts from a comprehensive
study that surveyed students, parents, teachers, counselors, and principals
regarding the perceptions and attitudes toward standardized testing.
A unique aspect of this study was the perception and attitudinal data
that was combined with student achievement data on the standardized
test they completed at the same time period of the survey administration.
The results presented in the various manuscripts from this study provided
new insight to the impact of standardized testing on student psychological
well-being and achievement.
The first paper
reported on surveys of 262 parents regarding their involvement and perceptions
of standardized testing and the impact on student achievement. Specifically,
parents were asked about their perceptions of teacher stress, student
stress, test value, and their level of involvement. The responses of
parents were associated with performance of their students on the standardized
assessment to examine the relationship between parental attitudes and
student outcomes.
The second paper
reported on surveys of 125 teachers regarding their attitudes and practices
related to standardized testing programs. Specifically, teachers were
asked about their perceptions of school climate and its effects on themselves
and their students. The responses of teachers were associated with
performance of students in their classrooms on the standardized assessment.
The third paper
was unique in that counselors and principals of the respective schools
were surveyed regarding the climate surrounding standardized testing.
In addition to questions regarding their own involvement in the testing
process, the survey addressed their perceptions of the impact of standardized
testing on students and teachers.
The fourth paper
surveyed 250 fifth graders during the week of the fall Stanford Achievement
Test-9th Edition. The surveys included questions measuring test anxiety,
school climate, and pressure. The purpose was to research students'
attitudes towards testing and how these attitudes affected academic
performance on the SAT-9.
The final paper,
"Students, Teachers, Parents, Counselors, and Administrators:
Are Their Perceptions Consistent With Reality?" integrated the
findings of the first four papers, to develop recommendations or guidelines
to address the issue of test anxiety in the educational system. In several
papers numerous inconsistencies were identified between the perceptions
of the students, teachers, parents, counselors, and administrators with
actual student achievement. This paper addressed these issues and provided
possible action items to help address these inconsistencies in perception
and performance.
Session 4.3 WRITING AND GETTING PUBLISHED (Training,
1 Hour) Salon D
Trainer:
John R. Petry, The University of Memphis
Opportunities and
problems associated with writing and publishing articles and manuscripts
were discussed. Topics included sources of ideas for research and writing,
guides for effective writing, elements of style, publication sources,
preparing and submitting a manuscript, ethics in authorship, understanding
the publishing process, and using writing/publishing for professional
development.
Objectives of the
session were to increase the awareness of opportunities to publish,
raise standards for writing quality manuscripts, and establish minimum
guidelines for professional growth. This session addressed pertinent
information designed to aid in the achievement of these goals.
Activities included
a diagnosis of the basic writing skills of attendees, analysis of articles
ready for submission to publications, and administration of a predictive
measure for publication success. A number of sources for publishing
were presented and discussed that gave the manuscript submitters a higher
chance of achieving success for acceptance. Participants' manuscripts
were evaluated for their content, style, impact on the reader, and value
to the scholarly community.
Important emphases
included: (1) knowing the audience to whom the publication is intended;
(2) knowing the expectations of the editor and journal and making sure
the article addressed its main point effectively; (3) having a definite
message and reason for writing; (4) writing correctly and distinctly;
(5) writing about subjects that the author knew;, (6) following the
style of the publisher's writing, knowing editor's preferences, and
using the journal's format; (7) understanding the publishing process,
how journals articles have been requested, reviewed, rewritten, and
accepted; (8) recognizing that the writing, reviewing, and editing processes
take time; and (9) following up on every submission, calling the editor
to determine status, and learning how to edit personal submissions.
* * * * Note: Bus Departs For UALR
At 1:45 P.M. * * * *
1:30
P.M. - 2:20 P.M.
Session 5.1 EVALUATION AND FUTURE DEVELOPMENT
OF A UNIVERSITY ACADEMIC SUPPORT PROGRAM (Symposium) Salon
A
Organizer:
Reid J. Jones, Delta State University
Overview
This symposium
presented a program report on the origins, design, strengths, and limitations
of an Academic Skills Laboratory (ASL) at a small, rural, southeastern
university. Quantitative and qualitative evidence was used to evaluate
program components. Plans for institutionalizing some program aspects
were discussed.
System-Wide Origins, Background, and
Initial Structure of the Academic Support Program
Nita Thornell, Delta State University
Data were presented
documenting the fact that for years many students graduating from Mississippi
high schools have been under‑prepared for university work. Recently,
the use of ACT "cut‑off" scores for admissions for the
state's public universities was ruled unacceptable. As a consequence,
universities began admitting students who would not have been eligible
in the past. A statewide academic support system was established with
laboratories at each of eight Institutions of Higher Learning (IHL).
Initially, the design for the laboratories was computer‑based
with a laboratory director and part-time support from faculty.
Placement Testing and Prescriptive
Activities in the Academic Support Laboratory
Joe Anderson, Delta State University
One hundred eighty‑one
students were required to participate in the ASL based on low ACT scores.
A computer‑based diagnostic testing program provided further information
on Reading Comprehension, Sentence Structure, College Based Mathematics,
and Elementary Algebra. Computer exercises and classroom work provided
support in each student's areas of greatest need. Reading comprehension
showed significant pre‑ and posttest improvement (F = 9.169; p
< .01). The other three areas all showed non‑significant gains
that approached the p = .05 level (F's ranged from 2.075 to 3.191).
Quantitative Evaluation of the Academic
Support Laboratory
Reid J. Jones and Carla Johnson, Delta
State University
Demographic information
(sex, ethnicity, and educational level of parents) from participating
students was shown to have significant (p <.05) associations with
ACT and diagnostic pretests. Evidence for concurrent validity of the
computer‑based tests was provided by significant (p < .05)
correlations with ACT scores. Follow‑up study of the student
GPA's, however, showed a mean of 1.88 out of a possible 4.0. GPA was
significantly (p < .05) associated with ACT Reading (Pearson r =
.40). Other quantitative associations were difficult to demonstrate,
probably influenced by severe restrictions on the range of variation
in these subjects. For example, all of the 181 students had ACT composite
scores between 12 and 21.
Discussion: Using Evaluation Information
in Planning for Future Academic Support Services
Information from
the past three years was used to begin planning for changes in the support
program. For example, reading comprehension practice and study skills
workshops have been incorporated into a required general education course
at the university. Other innovative concepts must be identified as
the support program evolves. Audience discussion of similar approaches
and solutions was encouraged.
Session 5.2 COLLEGE STUDENTS
Salon B
Chair:
Daphne Hubbard, University of South Alabama
The Intellectual
Development of White, Middle-Class, Female College Students: An Application
of Women's Ways of Knowing
Jennifer B. Hennessey, University of
Arkansas at Little Rock
This study investigated
the extent to which the theory of intellectual development of Belenky,
Clinchy, Goldberg, and Tarule, outlined in their 1997 book Womens
Ways of Knowing, adequately accounted for the intellectual development
of the participants interviewed.
In Belenkys
(et al.) Womens Ways of Knowing, a model of intellectual
development taking into consideration the innate differences between
men and women was developed from interviews with women. The participants
in this qualitative study were white, female, college students from
middle-class families. For the purpose of this study, social class
was defined by parental education and occupation.
Interviews were
conducted with four undergraduate students following the interview protocol
outlined in the book. These students were attending traditional four-year
colleges in Arkansas and Texas. The responses were compared to Belenkys
model of intellectual development. Themes present across all interviews
were labeled for discussion purposes.
The interviews
revealed the presence of the care perspective and the influence
of college instructors/professors on these womens lives. The
responses related to the care perspective included the womens
descriptions of themselves and past relationships, as well as the importance
they place on being a woman. All women stated that their caring nature
is what makes them as women different from men.
The implications
of this study included the following: the influence that a college
professor can have on a student can be either positive or negative.
These women reported that they did not need an authority figure to direct
their thinking. Each had her own ideas and opinions, only needing classroom
experiences to facilitate them in developing these ideas further.
Higher Education: Transmission of Educational
Values in Today's Society
Luz Marina Escobar and Warren G. Ortloff,
The University of Southern Mississippi
Literature in the
United States regularly addresses symptoms of the decline of morals,
values, and ethical behavior within its society. This decline has contributed
to an increase in interpersonal violence and other concerns that have,
in some cases, been correlated with decreased student academic achievement.
Schools have traditionally assumed the role of promoting societies'
values and, therefore, have assumed much of the blame. The university
that educates the future teacher, who will in turn educate and influence
children, has not been immune to this crisis.
This study examined
differences in college student values orientation over time through
comparing student value's hierarchy conducted in a nationwide study
by Rokeach in 1968 and more limited investigation by Escobar-Ortloff
in 1999 at a major, comprehensive public university in Mississippi.
In both instances, the Rokeach Values Survey was used as the instrument
of choice in measuring and comparing student value orientation. The
Rokeach survey requested respondents to rank order terminal (end-state
of existence) and instrumental (modes of conduct) values in order of
importance to them personally.
Rokeach, in 1972,
identified four instrumental values (responsible, capable, broad-minded,
and intellectual) and four terminal values (sense of accomplishment,
self-respect, wisdom, and freedom) that he found were perceived by educational
institutions, professors of education, and school administrators to
be important to those who valued education. This paper identified those
"educational" values, determined their orientation among and
between the Rokeach and Escobar-Ortloff studies, and offered to the
reader an explanation for differences in value orientation through the
philosophies of Logical Positivism, Utilitarism, and Personalism.
The Impact of Religious Belief on Learning
in the Science Classroom
Ann M. Findley, Sara J. Lindsey, and
Susie Watts, University of Louisiana at Monroe
Research shows
that one of the most important prerequisites for student success is
for teachers to understand and respect individuals from different cultures,
and to understand the communities from which they come (Ilmer, Snyder,
Erbaugh & Kurz, 1997). Thus, if we want students to succeed, what
they bring into the science classroom in terms of belief simply cannot
be ignored; fundamental beliefs have considerable impact on learning
(Cooper, 1996).
Two of the aims
of the Rural Systemic Initiatives Program (RSI), which is working in
21 of Louisianas rural, economically disadvantaged parishes, are
to address barriers to systemic and sustainable improvements in science
and to adapt high quality, challenging curricula to address cultural
diversity. With these aims in mind, a study was undertaken of 155 college
freshmen biology students in order to ascertain their preconceived beliefs
about the subject of evolution. At the end of their course, students
were given a survey in which they were asked to respond to questions
pertaining to their own high school biology education, and to their
beliefs concerning science, religion, and evolution. The survey consisted
of 11 items requiring a response based on a five-point Likert scale.
Four additional items required a yes/no response. Demographic data were
obtained, and dependent samples t-tests were used to analyze the mean
differences in scientific and religious beliefs between students from
rural disadvantaged parishes and students from other parishes in Louisiana.
The results showed
that there were indeed significant differences between the two groups.
Students from rural, disadvantaged parishes appear to accept that belief
and supernatural explanations are within the realms of science. These
findings suggested that science instruction in the rural parishes may
be less effective because of cultural beliefs and to understandings
regarding scientific study that students bring into the classroom.
Session 5.3 PARENTAL INVOLVEMENT Salon C
Chair:
George E. Marsh II, The University of Alabama
Teachers' Conception
of the Extent and Nature of Parental Involvement in the School Literacy
Programs in the Black Belt Region
Danjuma R. Saulawa, Alabama State University
This study was
designed to investigate the extent to which teachers in the Black Belt
Region of a southeastern state felt that parents should be involved
in curricular decisions, the ways in which they involved parents in
the literacy development of their children, and the three most important
ways they felt that parents could be involved in order to support the
literacy development of their children. An additional purpose of the
study was to find out if there was a difference between primary, upper
elementary, middle school, and high school teachers in their views about
parental involvement.
A three-item open
questionnaire was sent through graduate students representing 21 schools
from the Black Belt Region. A total of 168 teachers responded and
returned the questionnaire.
Both qualitative
and quantitative methods were used to analyze the data. The preliminary
results indicated ambivalence about parental involvement among the teachers.
While the majority of teachers indicated a support for parental involvement,
the extent and the nature of parental involvement seemed to vary with
grade levels. Implications of the results of this study for teacher
education were discussed.
Palm Pilots, Pagers and Parents
Paris Strom, Auburn University
When teachers are asked to identify the changes needed
to motivate greater student success, parent involvement is mentioned
more frequently than any other factor. The most troubling concern of
teachers involves a growing number of parents who do not return phone
messages about a childs misbehavior, appear unwilling to reinforce
school conduct codes, and fail to attend conferences. One outcome of
this trend is a gradual increase in the share of responsibility for
student discipline assigned to the school.
Teachers maintain that only parents have the authority
to carry out the unique role of guiding social and emotional development
of their children. Rapid notification of student behavior is needed
for parents to provide timely corrective guidance on misconduct or reinforce
commendable action. However, it is often difficult for teachers to contact
parents who are working away from home, who do not have answering machines,
or whose children erase messages.
The goals of this pilot project supported by Motorola
were to assess a system for teachers to document favorable and unfavorable
behaviors of students and quickly notify their parents. Thirteen high
school faculty were trained to use wireless organizers for recording
coded student behavior and sending messages by pager. Parents of 100
students received and confirmed messages sent by teachers for one semester.
When a parent received a coded pager message, he/she discussed the issue
with the child. Data were transferred to the teachers computer
for recordkeeping.
Urban School Principals
Concept of the Relative Importance of Parental Involvement Among School
Improvement Elements
Hae-Seong Park, University of New Orleans
The purpose of
this study was to examine the urban school principals' concept of the
relative importance of parent involvement among seven major school improvement
elements. A sample of urban school principals (n=102) was drawn in the
New Orleans area. Descriptive statistics and multiple regression were
employed to exhibit the principals self-reported concept for the
relative importance of parent involvement and its association with principals
evaluations for their schools existing condition for Epstein's
five types of parent involvement.
The rank of the
relative importance of parent involvement was fifth among seven elements.
The most important school improvement element was emphasizing powerful
learning activities (mean = 2.68) in the classroom, while the least
important school improvement was infusing technology into the curriculum
(mean = 5.28).
To predict the
concept of the importance of parent involvement for urban school principals,
only the type of parent involvement in decision making among Epstein's
five types of parent involvement was found as a significant factor.
Suggestions for future research were offered.
Session
5.4 READING / LITERACY Riverside East
Reliability of
the Elementary Reading Attitude Survey (ERAS)
Rachael Flynn, Lorie Taylor, Leigh Ann
Beard, Dixie Turnbo, and Richard Kazelskis, The University of Southern
Mississippi
The reliability
of Elementary Reading Attitude Survey (ERAS) scores was examined by
obtaining Cronbach's alphas and test‑retest coefficients for the
recreational subscale, academic subscale, and the total scale scores.
The responses of 718 students in the fourth, fifth, and sixth grades
were used in the analysis. A seven-day test-retest interval was utilized.
The recreational
and academic subscale scores and the total scale scores of the ERAS
were analyzed by gender, ethnicity, and grade level. The alpha coefficients
suggested adequate internal consistency across gender, ethnicity, and
grade level, with all coefficients being above the .75 level.
The test-retest
coefficients associated with gender and ethnicity were slightly below
the .70 level, ranging from .57 to .67, with the highest coefficients
being for the total scale. Test-retest coefficients for the recreational
subscale scores for female students were slightly higher than for males,
but the test-retest coefficients for the academic subscale and the total
scale scores for male students were higher than for females. Test-retest
reliabilities for the recreational and academic subscales and the total
scale scores were notably higher for African American students than
for European American students. All of the test-retest correlation
coefficients by grade level were acceptable, ranging from .70 to .83.
Test-retest reliabilities found in the present study were comparable
to, or larger than, those reported by McKenna and Kear, authors of the
ERAS. The findings of the study suggested that total scores on the
ERAS might be slightly more reliable than the subscale scores.
Reliability of
the Student Literacy Attitude Inventory (SLAI)
Patti Smith, Thea Williams-Hayes, Yu-Hsing
Chang, and Carolyn Reeves-Kazelskis, The University of Southern Mississippi
Responses of 367
students in grades four, five, and six to the Student Literacy Attitude
Inventory (SLAI) were used to examine the internal consistency (Cronbach's
alphas) and test‑retest reliabilities of SLAI scores. The data
were analyzed by gender, ethnicity, and grade level for each SLAI subarea
(listening, speaking, reading, writing, and self-perceptions as learners)
and SLAI total scores. The test‑retest interval was seven days.
The alphas associated
with the total SLAI scores ranged from .91 to .94 across gender, ethnicity,
and grade level, but alpha coefficients for the subarea scores were
lower ranging from .60 to .79 across the same groups. The test-retest
coefficients for SLAI total scores were above .70 for all three grade
levels, for females, and for African American students. The only test‑retest
coefficient below .70 for SLAI total scores was for males (.67). For
the SLAI subareas, the test-retest correlation coefficients associated
with gender and grade level ranged from .44 to .74, with the highest
correlations being associated with the subarea of speaking for female
students (.71) and for fifth‑grade students (.74).
Overall, the results
indicated that total scores of the SLAI were acceptably reliable across
the groups examined, suggesting that total scores appeared to be useful
in assessing the extent to which students may respond positively to
literacy programs that included multiple instructional strategies that
incorporate language arts activities. The reliabilities for the subarea
scores suggested that subarea scores should be used with caution, pending
further study of the various SLAI subareas.
A Review of the
Literature on Pre-Kindergarten Cognitive Academic Language Assessment
Instruments Suitable for Use in Culturally and Ethnically Diverse School
Systems
Marie Miller-Whitehead, Tennessee Valley
Educators for Excellence
Although there
are many regions of the country that have historically been ethnically
and linguistically diverse, school system data and information from
the 2000 census and other sources have indicated that many hitherto
homogeneous regions of the country and their educational institutions
have experienced significant growth in populations of immigrant children
and their families. Thus, many school systems have faced new challenges
to meet the needs of these children from diverse cultural and linguistic
backgrounds, including issues related to providing bilingual or ESL
education for their Limited English Proficient children.
Sources were selected
from current extant psychometric reviews, the United States Department
of Education, the Council of Chief State School Officers, the Center
for Applied Linguistics, the various ERIC Clearinghouses, the United
States Census Bureau, and position and policy papers on ESL and ELL
student testing and placement from AERA, CRESST, and CREDE.
The review examined
the literature for approaches used to determine content, construct,
and predictive validity of kindergarten cognitive diagnostic assessments
and their usefulness for making decisions about pre-kindergarten students
and groups of students from ethnically diverse populations. The paper
sought to identify the most current literature related to the examination
of item domain goals and objectives, sources for sample items that could
be useful to equate with other pre-kindergarten assessments for the
purpose of developing item banks that measure children's cognitive academic
language proficiency, and to examine the extant literature on differences
in skill attainment of preschool male and female children and children
from ethnic minority groups identified as LEP or ELL.
Also addressed
were some of the pitfalls to be aware of in assessing ethnically and
socioeconomically diverse populations of preschool children, assessment
items and item wording that might present difficulties for ELL children,
and issues involved in using dichotomous or polytomous rating scales
for scoring performance assessments.
Session 5.5
COMPUTER EDUCATION / TECHNOLOGY Riverside West
Chair:
Allison Potter, The University of Memphis
Chat: The Missing Link in On-line Instruction
As more courses
in higher education move to an on-line format, a major concern that
has arisen is the lack of personal interaction between the professor
and student. Literature has provided evidence that, often, courses delivered
on-line have tended to be configured and delivered in a style more often
associated with independent study or correspondence work, i.e., students
working independently to complete posted assignments at their own pace.
While this format may work in some areas, it leaves a "missing
link" in the learning curve for students because they lack the
opportunity to benefit from the experience of structured dialogue and
the sense of community that can be created in a traditional on-site
classroom environment.
This research paper
presented evidence based on the authors' direct experience in delivering
two sections of a graduate course taught via on-line format. Further,
the paper detailed how to effectively employ chat technology and e-mail
to more actively engage students and professors in the learning process.
Additionally, the paper suggested specific activities and delivery styles
that allowed professors to utilize Socratic teaching methods, use chat
rooms for small- and large-group dialogue and/or project development,
build a sense of community, and allow for peer evaluation and feedback
of student produced artifacts. The paper provided evidence that utilization
of the chat room and frequent e-mail afforded students the benefits
of shared knowledge via dialogue from peers and the professor. Conversely,
the professor benefits from the ability to monitor student progress
and adjust instruction to meet the evolving needs of students. Finally,
the authors presented evaluative findings based on a piloted team-taught
course and shared the end-of-course student feedback.
An Evaluative
Approach to Student Responses from a Video-Conferencing and On-line
Survey: An Appraisal Approach Based on Accreditation
Sherri L. Restauri, Franklin L. King,
and J. Gordon Nelson, Jacksonville State University
There is a requirement
for close examination of the needs of the students in the distance-learning
environment in order to provide the best possible learning environment.
This assessment may in turn lead to modest or extensive modification
in teaching methodology. Criteria used to measure student satisfaction
may be drawn from must items presented by an accrediting
agency. Two of the most popular delivery formats in distance education
involve video-conferencing and on-line delivery methodologies. Each
of these formats possesses certain variables that must be approached
differently and skillfully by the instructors.
The first step
in this process of recognition and reorganization needed for all forms
of distance education is to identify the differences that exist between
the traditional delivery classroom environment and the classroom that
is either augmented or replaced by one of these formats. In order to
accomplish this, an analysis of preference for student campus visits,
instructor visitation/rotation, class orientation, teaching delivery
style, and student-learning approach was performed in this study by
means of an anonymous survey sent out to all students in on-line and
video-conferencing classes. Student comparisons between the two major
formats and traditional classroom characteristics were gathered, as
well as student demographic data. Data were accumulated for all courses
taught in the spring semester and entered into a statistical program
for analysis. Results were reported in percentages.
The results revealed
a clear preference for particular teaching delivery styles and mode
of learning material within each of these two categories of implementation.
Certain variables in the comparison category revealed that student satisfaction
with the class might have been highly dependent upon the ease with which
the material can be viewed or accessed, independent of the format being
used. It was necessary for instructors, departments, and accrediting
agencies to take into account technological skills limitations of students
in classes utilizing the on-line format, as well as to emphasize near
perfection in performance of equipment in video conferencing. Additional
training for instructors who are or will be utilizing any of the formats
may improve the adaptation of material into proper format suitable for
teaching through the selected method of teaching. In addition, training
has now been implemented in the on-line course format to overcome the
technological skills deficit that many of these students hold at the
beginning of the class.
Speaking with
Interactive Educational Television Directors in Secondary Schools: Is
IETV Making the Grade?
Patty M. Reed, Louisiana State University,
and Peggy Doviak, University of Oklahoma
The study examined
the use of interactive educational television (IETV) in secondary school
classrooms. Distance education directors were asked to respond to questions
involving the use of IETV programs within their schools. Some of the
questions concerned the expectations, effectiveness, and support of
these programs.
Twenty-three high
schools were randomly chosen. Sixteen schools presently used IETV, five
previously used IETV, and two never used IETV. The participants for
the study were the directors of the IETV programs. The size of the
schools ranged from less than 100 students to over 2000 students with
IETV enrollment ranging from three to 60. Of the 21 schools that used
or previously used IETV classes the programs had been in place on the
average of three to five years. Classes offered in the IETV programs
ranged from required courses such as English and math to elective courses
such as business marketing and family relations.
Data for the study
were collected through questionnaires by mail, questionnaires by e-mail,
and phone interviews. Some of the statements on the questionnaires
that the participants responded to were as follows: (1) students are
given the same opportunities for participation as students in the host
school classrooms, and (2) I am satisfied with the progress students
have made in the IETV courses. Phone interviews were conducted with
each participant concerning the history of their IETV programs, as well
as their questionnaire responses.
Data were analyzed
both holistically and analytically. Graphs were used to show distributions
of responses and emerging patterns of data. Even though this study
was exploratory in nature and not conclusive, data indicated that most
of the participants were satisfied with their IETV programs. However,
some concerns were expressed in the area of interaction for the programs.
Data suggested implications for IETV directors, IETV teachers, and school
administrators.
* * * * Note: Bus Departs For UALR
At 2:45 P.M. * * * *
2:30 P.M. - 3:20 P.M.
Session 6.1 INTERNATIONAL EDUCATION Salon A
Chair:
Abraham Andero, Alabama State University
From Yellow Peril To Model
Minority: The Transition of Asian Americans
Srilata Bhattacharyya, The University
of Memphis
The academic achievements
of students belonging to different ethnic minority groups have interested
researchers in a multicultural society like the United States. Researchers
are perplexed at the phenomenal educational success of Asian Americans,
now referred to as the model minority. Scholars have posited
various theories, yet there was a dearth of comprehensive literature
that indicates the pertinent reasons. This article was a critical review
of the empirical and theoretical literature on the academic achievement
of Asian Americans.
An extensive computer search of databases, such as ERIC
and Psychological Abstracts was done, followed by a manual search of
books and journals in the behavioral and social sciences. The key words
were Asian American, academic/educational, excellence/achievement.
The earlier stereotypical
image portrayed Asians as yellow peril, a threat to White
America, with regard to labor and occupations. It took about 150
years for the transition to the recent portrayal of model minority,
mainly based on the educational excellence and occupational performance.
This can be attributed to a multiplicity of factors, the prominent ones
being the cultural and parental values embedded in the structure and
nature of the Asian family.
Some of the key
determinants of academic achievement of group were identified, and potential
factors for success /failure were discussed. The historical bases of
immigration revealed that various Asian countries have immigrated because
of differing political, social, and economic reasons, and should not
be considered as a monolithic group, irrelevant of the cultural identity,
country of origin, and reasons for migration, as there are inherent
differences in the ethnic groups.
An analysis of
the attributions for the exceptional academic achievement of Asian Americans
may contribute to the school success of other ethnic minority groups
in this pluralistic society. A socio-cultural approach to education
would thus help.
A Comparison of the Education Systems
of the United States, the Republic of Korea, and Sri Lanka
Soo‑Back Moon, Catholic University
Of Daegue (Korea), and Gunapala Edirisooriya and James E. Mclean, East
Tennessee State University
Each country's
educational system is based on an educational philosophy that is the
product of many years of tradition and practice. Education is designed
to further the goals of society by acculturating the youth. The purpose
of this paper was to examine the educational systems in the United States,
the Republic of Korea, and Sri Lanka in terms of their educational philosophies.
In the United States,
the educational system is based on the underlying premise that all
students should receive an education. Koreans have traditionally placed
great importance on education with the dual goals of personal advancement
and self-fulfillment. The education system in Sri Lanka has its roots
in the Pririvena education system, which was organized by community-based
Buddhist temples as a voluntary social service activity. However, following
the British colonization of the whole island, they established a system
of public education which Sri Lanka inherited, including its philosophy,
teaching methods, curriculum, assessment, organization, administration,
and so on.
Compulsory school
attendance, access for special education students in their least restrictive
environment, and access for disabled students are all products of the
underlying educational philosophy in the United States. The education
system of Korea includes six-year elementary schools, three-year middle
schools, and four-year high schools as well as colleges and universities.
All citizens are required to attend elementary school, resulting in
one of the highest literacy rates in the world. In Sri Lanka, education
is free from at least kindergarten though the tenth grade. Only those
successfully completing an examination continue beyond Grade 10.
An appropriate
evaluation of the educational systems of these countries relates to
how well the systems support the county's goals for education. The
full paper compared and contrasted the educational systems in light
of the philosophies upon which each was based and the forces that influenced
their development.
Two Cultures Under
One Roof: A Comparison of Mexican and American High School Students
at Stratford High School in Nashville, Tennessee
Melissa B. Graves, Tennessee State University
The relationship
between student achievement, student culture, a practitioner's attitude
and expectations were investigated at Stratford High School in Nashville,
Tennessee. Student achievement was defined as academic performance but
also included perceptions, rationales, and explanations for student
behaviors and conduct. Student culture described students' Mexican
American origins, customs, and beliefs to a limited degree. The practitioner's
attitude described how one high school teacher perceived an underachieving
and a high achieving Mexican student in an inner-city high school and
included expectations and some description of interactions between American
high school teachers and the students interviewed. The practitioner
in this case was a white, American female.
Results indicated
that Mexican American students perceived themselves and school personnel
perceived these students as different from black and white American
students. Mexican American cultural traditions were also perceived
as inferior and disadvantageous by a high achieving Mexican American
student and by personnel. Underachieving Mexican American students
generally valued their cultural traditions more positively than high
achieving students and became resistant to learning when these traditions
were marginalized in school. Student achievement was also related to
student compliance, student appearance, styles in written and verbal
communication and the practitioner's perceptions about the willingness
of Mexican American students to practice and support United States norms.
These findings
agreed with theories that discussed relationships between student achievement,
student culture, and practitioners' attitudes and expectations. Theories
about school failure occurring less frequently in minority groups that
were positively oriented toward their own and the dominant culture were
contradicted in this research.
Session 6.2 RESEARCH METHODS/STATISTICS Salon C
Chair: Gail H. Weems, The University of
Memphis
A Proposed New
What If Reliability Analysis for Assessing the Statistical
Significance of Bivariate Relationships
Anthony J. Onwuegbuzie, Howard University;
Larry G. Daniel, University of North Florida; and J. Kyle Roberts, University
of North Texas
One of the assumptions
underlying null hypothesis significance tests (NHST) is that all variables
involved are measured without error. Unfortunately, when measurement
errors are present, as is typically the case in the social and behavioral
sciences, the relationships computed from the sample data will systematically
underestimate the strength of the associations in the population. In
the two-variable case, errors of measurement yield biased estimates
of correlation coefficients that attenuate the true relationships. Indeed,
the greater the measurement error, the more the correlation coefficient
is attenuated. Thus, knowledge of the error of estimate, as indexed
by the reliability coefficient, is vital.
Recently, there
have been calls for the reporting of sample-specific reliability coefficients
and confidence intervals around reliability coefficients. However, the
fact that most researchers do not report reliability estimates for their
own data suggests that rhetoric is not sufficient to reverse this trend.
Rather, what is needed is more compelling evidence of how information
about current-sample specific reliability estimates can facilitate data
analysis and interpretation.
Thus, the purpose
of the present paper was twofold. First, the authors illustrated how
displaying disattenuated correlation coefficients alongside their unadjusted
counterparts allowed the reader to assess the impact of unreliability
on each bivariate relationship.
Second, they demonstrated
how a proposed new "what if reliability" analysis could complement
the conventional NHST of bivariate relationships. Such analyses indicated
how large a reliability coefficient was needed to obtain statistical
significance for an observed correlation coefficient in cases where
the null hypothesis was not rejected, as well as how small a reliability
coefficient was needed before an observed statistically significant
relationship was no longer statistically significant. As such, "what
if reliability" analyses helped researchers interpret their results
by considering the extent to which the reliability coefficient(s) yielded,
or failed to yield, statistical significance.
A Monte Carlo Investigation of New
Measures of Score Reliability and Homogeneity
J. Kyle Roberts, University of North
Texas, and Anthony J. Onwuegbuzie, Howard University
Much of the current
research concerning reliability emphasized that researchers gather their
own reliability estimates when administering an instrument, even if
that instrument has been previously validated. It has also recommended
that data with low reliability estimates then be discarded. While some
data obtained from instruments that originally yielded reliable results
may be unreliable, researchers have documented that it does not necessarily
imply that the underlying data are not useful.
This paper contended
that, although data from a homogeneous sample might yield less reliable
scores than did an inducted sample, these data should not be discarded
until further examination of the data is conducted. In order to help
researchers investigate the disattenuation of reliability estimates,
the authors examined the following two recently developed statistics:
(1) alpha-ROE and (2) the relative mean item variance (RMIV) index.
Both statistics provided a measure of score homogeneity. Alpha-ROE,
which ranges from 0 to 1, indicates the amount of the lack of total
test score variance (and individual item variance) that is due to score
homogeneity. The RMIV ranges from ¥ to 1, with positive values indicating
that the (low) reliability coefficient is the result of score homogeneity
(with respect to the original test manual dataset).
The researchers
investigated the properties of these indices via a Monte Carlo technique.
Specifically, this procedure was used to document the acceptable and
non-acceptable parameter values of alpha-ROE and the RMIV index for
various levels of decrease in Cronbachs alpha coefficient. The
resulting information will allow future researchers to correct their
reliability estimate for their observed levels of score homogeneity
as measured by alpha-ROE and the RMIV index. As such, the presenters
contended that this study represented a useful and necessary next step
in the development of these homogeneity statistics.
Session
6.3 DEVELOPING ON-LINE DEGREE PROGRAMS: ADVANTAGES OF THE VIDEO-STREAMING
MODEL (Training, 2 Hours) UALR
Trainers:
Larry R. Dickerson and William E. Garner, University of Arkansas
at Little Rock
This training
session discussed and demonstrated the techniques used to develop and
implement a new, completely on-line graduate degree program in Rehabilitation
Counseling (MRC) at the University of Arkansas at Little Rock. This
method used videostreaming technology, chromakey equipment, and Microsoft
PowerPoint to present lecture materials on-line in an asynchronous video
format. With this approach, the on-line content and experience was
very similar to what a student would encounter in attending a class
on-campus. This methodology allowed the program to place 13 courses
on-line in a 15-month span partially because the approach was very user
friendly for faculty members.
Participants developed
an understanding of how to apply this model for on-line courses/degree
programs to their specific needs. Topics included: (1) technology
requirements, (2) university and administrative issues, (3) staff and
support requirements, (4) faculty enlistment and training, (5) course
development and implementation, (6) student recruitment at the national
and international level, (7) integration with the BlackBoard Instructional
Webframe, (8) day-to-day operations and issues, and (9) accessibility
for persons with disabilities.
This training
session took place in the Distance Education Classroom and Lab on the
University of Arkansas at Little Rock campus where all MRC course videostreams
are produced. The participants were allowed to see direct demonstration
of the process and get hands-on experience with the techniques used.
Participants had the opportunity to deliver a simulated on-line presentation
using the chromakey technology.
Session 6.4 TECHNOLOGY UALR
Chair:
W. Keith Christy, University of Arkansas
at Little Rock
Basic Statistics On-line and in Class
Robert L. Kennedy, University of Arkansas,
Little Rock, and Corliss Jean Mccallister, The Anthony School
The study compared
the effectiveness of traditional, electronic mail and combination approaches
for teaching graduate introductory statistics classes. The electronic
mail course that was the focus of this study was offered in the 1997-2000
fall terms under the same instructor. All sections integrated the use
of a computer program for data analysis.
There were 41 participants
in the traditional (only) classes, 20 in the electronic (only), and
28 using both methods, with a majority membership of white females.
Twenty-item multiple-choice pretests and posttests on basic statistical
topics were given. An analysis of covariance (ANCOVA) was run using
posttest scores as the response variable and pretest scores as the covariate.
The ANCOVA technique involved features of both the analysis of variance
and regression, so assumptions for both were tested. Random selection
was not possible because students were allowed to participate in any
version of the course they thought most appropriate for them. Normality
and homoscedasticity across all groups were verified using the Omnibus
Normality of Residuals and Modified-Levene Equal-Variance tests. Treatment
and control groups observed homogeneity of regression in scatterplots
of pretest scores versus posttest scores and their trend lines.
The test indicated
that the null hypothesis of no statistically significant difference
among the traditional (adjusted mean of 6.17, n=41), electronic (adjusted
mean of 6.83, n=20), and both traditional and electronic (adjusted mean
of 6.94, n=28) classes' scores could not be rejected at the 0.05 level
[F(2,85)=1.15, p=0.32]. The effect size, f=0.16, was small (Cohen).
It was concluded, then, that offering the course using a traditional
approach, electronic mail, or a combination of approaches, seemed to
neither help nor hinder the performance of the students to the extent
measured by the multiple-choice tests.
Computing in Class and Attitudes Toward
Statistics
Robert L. Kennedy, University of Arkansas,
Little Rock, and Corliss Jean Mccallister, The Anthony School
The study investigated
the attitudes toward statistics of graduate students who studied advanced
statistics in which the focus of instruction was the use of a computer
program in class. The use of the program made it possible to provide
an individualized, self-paced, student-centered, and activity-based
course. The three sections involved in this study were offered in the
2001 spring term. Complete data were obtained form 19 participants.
Fifteen were in advanced statistics, and four were in multivariate statistics,
with the majority being white females. The instrument used was the
Statistics Attitude Survey (Roberts and Bilderback, 1980).
Both chi-square
(10.55, p=0.03) and Kendall's Coefficient of Concordance W (0.04, p=0.65)
indicated that there were differences in the distributions of ranks
between the pretest and posttest survey results. Most of these differences
occurred as increases in the rankings marked at each end of the scales.
That is, after the course, more students felt more strongly that they
agreed or disagreed with statements about some aspects of statistics.
For example, students agreed more strongly that "Statistics will
be useful to me when I describe my professional activities to other
people," and "I find statistics to be very logical and clear."
On the other hand, they disagreed more strongly that "When I solve
a statistics problem, I am often unsure if I have a correct or nearly
correct answer," and "Statistics is the most difficult course
I have taken." Comments from open-ended evaluation forms may help
explain the results of the survey, such as: "given the freedom
to learn at my own pace and style," "liked the structure of
class," "class flexibility," "final projects,"
and "relaxed environment." It was concluded, then, that offering
the course using computers may help improve students' attitudes about
certain aspects of statistics.
Observations About Alternative Data
Collection Techniques in Qualitative Research: E-Mail, Save-To-Disk,
and Taped Interviews
Gary M. Stiler, University Of Southern
Indiana
Traditional data collection methods for qualitative research
include copious note taking and taped interviews with subsequent transcription
and analysis. As an alternative, a case study was conducted using interviews
completed by e-mail between informant and interviewer. At the onset,
this process seemed to offer advantages with regard to efficiency, thoroughness,
and flexibility. Furthermore, Wilson, Lowry, Koneman, and Osman-Jouchoux
(1996) suggested that e-mail interviews decrease respondent anxiety
and increase the accuracy of their statements.
After an extended review of the proposed e-mail collection
methodology by the Human Participant Review Committee, a workable data
collection plan was negotiated and approved. However, as participant
interviews were initiated, it was found that the exclusive use of e-mail
as a data collection mechanism was untenable. Variations were subsequently
incorporated. These included the preparation of responses by participants
on word processors and transmittal of hard copy documents, a save-to-disk
procedure, and traditional taped interviews with subsequent transcription.
The use of e-mail
in qualitative data collection has potential. Through a review of the
steps taken in developing and revising the data collection procedures,
it is believed that qualitative researchers will be able to refine this
potentially valuable methodology. Furthermore, findings suggested that
by using a mix of data collection techniques, the quality and validity
of data could be enhanced.
* * * * NOTE: BUS DEPARTS FOR UALR
AT 4:00 P.M. * * * *
3:30 P.M. - 4:20 P.M.
Session 7.1 TEACHER EDUCATION / TECHNOLOGY UALR
Chair: Robert L. Kennedy, University of
Arkansas at Little Rock
Technology Training for Preservice
Teachers: Challenges for Colleges of Education
Linda F. Cornelious, Mississippi State
University
Teacher training
institutions are currently facing the overwhelming task of preparing
preservice teachers for technology-enhanced classrooms. There is significant
pressure on colleges of education to graduate students who are knowledgeable
about technology and are equipped to use it effectively. During the
past decade, teachers and teacher training institutions have been impacted
significantly by the growth of technology in education, and this trend
is not likely to change. Even though computers are now available in
most schools, not all preservice teachers see the value of using computers
to complement their instructional methods. If preservice or inservice
teachers demonstrate proficiency in integrating technology into their
teaching but do not believe technology has a use in the classroom, then
they will probably not teach using technology.
The purpose of
this paper was to review the literature to identify the basic components
of teacher training that may need to be transformed so that teachers
who graduate from institutions of higher learning are prepared and comfortable
in the use of technology as an instructional tool. The paper also described
preservice teachers attitudes toward computers and technology, and preservice
teachers and technology self-efficacy.
Preparing preservice
teachers to use computer-related technology in the classroom should
be a major concern of the faculty in all teacher preparation institutions.
Preparation must first begin with faculty serving as role models by
using technology to facilitate instruction in their own classes, allowing
students to observe the use of technology in the various disciplines.
This paper suggested how research on faculty use of technology in well-designed
preservice teaching training programs can enhance classroom practice,
improve student achievement, and ultimately contribute to teacher and
student proficiency and productivity.
Encouraging Student Teachers Via Electronic
Mail
Linda H. Thornton, Harding University
In January 2001,
44 elementary and special education student teachers enrolled in a professional
seminar course were randomly assigned to one of two groups; 43 student
teachers received e-mail messages from the professors regarding exams,
job openings, and links to helpful Internet sites. In addition, both
groups received from the professor inspirational e-mail messages tied
to Pathwise competencies encouraging them to maintain a high level of
performance.
Twenty-two student
teachers were assigned to receive more frequent encouraging e-mail messages
from the professor, and 22 student teachers were assigned to receive
less frequent encouraging e-mail messages. The group assigned to receive
more frequent encouragement received 21 inspirational messages throughout
the semester in addition to the procedural and informational messages.
The group assigned to receive less frequent encouragement received seven
inspirational messages throughout the semester in addition to the procedural
and informational messages. One student from the more frequent messages
group was dropped from the study because she had problems with her e-mail
account and was unable to check her messages throughout most of the
semester. This left 21 student teachers in the more frequent message
group and 22 student teachers in the less frequent message group.
The groups were
compared on three dependent variables-scores on the Praxis II Principles
of Learning and Teaching Exam, scores on the Harding University Field
Experience Observation System Assessment, and success in finding a teaching
position in fall 2001.
Student Teachers' Ability and Use of
Technology
Joanna P. Dickey, Shirley Long, and
Sue Reehm, Eastern Kentucky University
This paper described findings from a study that explored
student teachers competencies in relation to the Kentucky Department
of Educations technology standard for new and experienced teachers.
Eastern Kentucky University student teachers in elementary, middle grades,
secondary, and special education certification areas were asked in May
2001 to complete a survey designed to rate their perceived ability and
use of technology during student teaching.
Survey participants (elementary N = 43, middle grades
N = 26, secondary N = 59, special education N = 10) were asked to rate
their performance on 27 criteria in each of four different performance
areas. Participants rated their performance on a Likert scale (range
1 - 5) for: (1) ability, (2) frequency of use, (3) opportunities as
a student teacher, and (4) observation of cooperative teachers
use of technology.
Mean scores for
each group of survey participants were computed and analyzed for all
27 criteria in each of the four performance areas. Criteria were considered
as met if the mean score value equaled or exceeded 3.00
on the 1-5 scale. Results indicated that: (1) all groups met a high
majority of the criteria in the area of ability, and (2) the number
of criteria met by each group differed among the four performance areas.
A series of t-tests computed to analyze these differences revealed that
student ratings were significantly higher (p<.01) for ability than
for the other three areas.
A regression analysis
was computed to analyze students ability, frequency of use, and
cooperating teachers use as predictors of technology use during
student teaching. Results indicated that frequency of use and cooperating
teachers use were significant predictors (p<.01) of opportunity
to use technology by student teachers, while ability was not a significant
predictor. These findings have important implications for undergraduate
teacher preparation programs.
Session 7.2 INTRODUCTION
TO SOCIAL NETWORK ANALYSIS: APPLICATIONS FOR EDUCATIONAL RESEARCHERS
(Training, 1 Hour) UALR
Russell F. West, East Tennessee State
University
This training session
provided an introduction to the analysis of social networks in schools.
Social relationships have long been considered important in the behaviors
and opinions of students. While educators have recognized the importance
of social structure in the development of children and youth, there
has been little emphasis placed on assessing the nature of these relationships
and using this information to help explain achievement in schools.
Social network analysis includes a recent set of methods that can be
used in the study of social structures of children. Specifically, the
UCINET 5.0 and KRACKPLOT 3.0 microcomputer programs represent two tools
that allow researchers to assess the characteristics of these social
structures.
The purpose of
this session was to introduce participants to some of the major concepts
used in the analysis of social networks and the UCINET 5.0 and KRACKPLOT
3.0 microcomputer programs. Participants were able to: (1) identify
major network concepts associated with the analysis of social structure,
(2) recognize common strategies for collecting information about networks,
and (3) describe the process for inputting network data into the UCINET
5.0 and KRACKPLOT 3.0 microcomputer programs and estimating individual
network properties (i.e., size/degree, density, heterogeneity, compositional
quality, centrality, and power) and group properties (group density,
centralization, and homophily).
The session began
with an introduction to the use of social network research and the basic
concepts and terms used describing social structure. Participants gained
an understanding of network properties and methods of data collection
through a hands-on examination of their own ego-centered networks and
organizations. A more complex school application was demonstrated on
the microcomputer using the UCINET 5.0 and KRACKPLOT 3.0 programs.
The session ended with a discussion of other potential uses of these
analytical tools in assessing social structures in schools.
Session 7.3 DISPLAYS UALR
Age and Ethnic Variations in Family
Process Mediators of SES
Robert Flynn Corwyn and Robert H. Bradley,
University of Arkansas at Little Rock
Many of the ecological
developmental models that have been proposed to explain the relation
between socioeconomic status (SES) and child development include aspects
of children's home environments, such as the amount of cognitive stimulation
available and parental responsiveness. Most researchers have concentrated
their efforts on specific developmental periods even though many of
the putative mechanisms have been assumed to have operated throughout
most of childhood. Although current research in this area has moved
toward understanding processes, unknown is the extent to which particular
home environmental processes specified in proposed developmental models
actually have mediated relations between SES and various aspects of
child well‑being during each major developmental period. There
is both empirical and theoretical support for believing that some mediators
will be less potent during adolescence than early childhood, and that
these relations will differ across various cultural groups.
The purpose of
this study was to examine two aspects of the home environment frequently
included in SES/child development mediational models (learning stimulation,
maternal responsiveness) from early childhood to adolescence using data
from the National Longitudinal Survey of Youth (NLSY) - a national survey
of youth development. These relations were examined for three developmental
outcomes (vocabulary attainment, achievement test performance, and problem
behaviors) in three ethnic groups (African American, European American,
Latino). SES was operationalized with the Duncan SEI scale, learning
stimulation and maternal responsiveness were derived from subscales
of the NLSY HOME‑Short Form, behavior problems were measured with
the Behavior Problems Index (BPI Items were mostly derived from the
Achenbach Child Behavior Checklist), math achievement and reading comprehension
were taken from the Peabody Individual Achievement Test (PIAT), and
receptive vocabulary was measured by the Peabody Picture Vocabulary
Test ‑ Revised (PPVT‑R). Results found evidence that the
home environment sometimes mediates the relation between SES and child
outcomes, and the findings differed across ethnic groups.
Parental Involvement
and Students' Academic Achievement: Tests of Differential Effects Across
Four Asian Groups
Robert Flynn Corwyn and Ting Steven
Tieng Sing, University of Arkansas at Little Rock
Research on parental
involvement has received increased attention in recent years. The importance
of parental involvement is clearly exemplified by evidence that parental
involvement plays a key role in promoting academic success, the salient
role it plays in current educational reform, and by the increased educational
expectations placed on young students in the United States. Moreover,
an increase in the proportion of race and ethnic adolescents has contributed
to a growing number of studies that make comparisons across different
ethnic groups. These studies, however, typically combine all Asian groups
into one monolithic group even though the available evidence, as well
as theory, would suggest that there are important differences in family
functioning between Japanese Americans, Chinese Americans, Korean Americans,
and Filipino American families.
This study sought
to determine if there were ethnic group differences between four Asian
groups (Japanese Americans, Chinese Americans, Korean Americans, and
Filipino Americans) in the effect of parental involvement on students'
academic achievement. Also investigated were: (1) the relative importance
of various types of parental involvement in predicting student academic
achievement, and (2) cross‑group differences in the importance
of various types of parental involvement in predicting student academic
achievement.
Data from the National
Educational Longitudinal Survey (NELS:88), a nationally representative
sample of American eighth graders in 1988, were utilized to test a model
that included five areas of parental involvement (parental aspirations,
parent-child communication, home structure, participation in school
activities, and provision of learning resources in the home) and controlled
for family characteristics and students previous achievement.
Race was found
to be a significant moderator of the effects of parental involvement
on student academic success. Moreover, cross-group differences were
found in the impact of various types of parental involvement, especially
with regard to the provision of learning resources and parental aspirations
among the Japanese.
Parental Involvement and Twelfth-Grade Students' Academic Achievement:
Tests of Differential Effects Between African American and European
American Students
Ting Steven Tieng Sing and Robert Flynn
Corwyn, University of Arkansas at Little Rock
Based on evidence that parental involvement has a positive
influence on student academic achievement, educational reform efforts,
educational expectations, and educational research have placed a high
priority on parental involvement. However, the relative influence of
different forms of parental involvement on student academic achievement
is not well understood. Moreover, even less is known about how the relations
between various types of parental involvement and student academic success
may differ across ethnic groups.
This study sought to determine if there were differences
between European American students and African American students in
the effect parental involvement has on their academic achievement. The
relative importance of various types of parental involvement, and group
differences in the importance of various types of parental involvement
in predicting student academic achievement were investigated.
Data from the National Educational Longitudinal Survey
(NELS:88), a nationally representative sample of American adolescents,
was used in order to test a model that included five areas of parental
involvement (parental aspirations, parent-child communication, home
structure, participation in school activities, provision of learning
resources in the home) and controlled for family characteristics and
student' previous achievement. Students were in the twelfth grade during
the 1992 school year.
Race was found
to be a significant moderator of the effects of parental involvement
on student academic success. Moreover, cross‑group differences
were found in the impact of various types of parental involvement.
* * * * Note: Final Bus Departs For
UALR At 4:30 P.M. * * * *
4:30 P.M. - 5:20 P.M.
Session 8.1 IMPLEMENTING STANDARDS THROUGH TECHNOLOGY
(Demonstration) UALR
Cheryl R. Grable, Barbara Stanford,
Pam Warrick, Shirley Freeman‑Turner, and Warren Kimmerly, University
of Arkansas at Little Rock
Preservice educators
are faced by a plethora of standards from NCATE, ISTE, state standards,
and standards implied in student examinations such as PRAXIS II. Secondary
educators must also meet content standards from national learned societies.
The authors presented an approach to integrating all of the standards
in a technology-enhanced, problem-based curriculum using EAST Lab technology
in both the university and cooperating secondary and middle level schools.
The presentation included highlights of successful development of curricula
throughout teacher education programs. The presenters were participants
in a United States Department of Education project: Preparing Tomorrow's
Teachers to Use Technology (PT3).
5:30 P.M. KEYNOTE
ADDRESS, FOLLOWED BY JOINT UNIVERSITIES RECEPTION UALR
Note: Buses Depart UALR For Doubletree
Hotel at 7:30 and 8:30 P.M.
top
|